Episode Description
For a lot of women, the ambition of their 20s, 30s, and 40s comes with a constant low hum of fear: of falling behind, of being replaced, of the work drying up the moment they slow down. Ana Gasteyer knows that feeling well. On Saturday Night Live, she hid her first pregnancy for five and a half months because she was afraid she’d lose her job.
Now 59, with a Tony nomination behind her and her biggest holiday tour yet ahead, Ana sits down with Tamsen Fadal to reflect on her career and how the fear has finally loosened its grip. What replaced it was knowing what she’s good at, choosing work for joy instead of survival, and making real room for the people she loves.
In this episode, you’ll hear:
- Why the “chased by a lion” anxiety of earlier decades can ease in midlife
- How much the culture has shifted since she was the first SNL cast member to be pregnant on the show
- Why she left SNL at 35, and what it takes to walk away from the thing that defines you
- How her son encouraged her to take on Broadway during his senior year of high school
- Her first Tony nomination and longtime friend Rachel Dratch’s reaction to the news
- Her take on comedy as truth-telling, and the women in comedy who paved the way for her
- The list of things she still wants to make in this chapter of her life
Timestamps
0:00 Intro
1:30 Why Ana made a holiday album and Sugar and Booze
4:42 Saying yes to what brings joy
7:20 The fear of falling behind in your 20s and 30s
8:46 Hiding her pregnancy on SNL
13:42 Friendships and careers after SNL
16:43 Women in comedy and telling the truth
19:24 Why Ana left SNL at 35
21:34 The list of things she still wants to make
23:07 Menopause jokes everywhere
25:25 What she no longer feels she has to prove
28:20 Her first Tony nomination
30:18 Taking Sugar and Booze on tour
33:03 Why there is no lion in your 50s
Share with a Friend
If you liked this episode, listen to these episodes
guest appearing in this episode
Ana Gasteyer
Ana Gasteyer is an actor, comedian and singer who spent six years on Saturday Night Live, which she joined in 1996, and has been in six Broadway shows. This year she earned her first Tony nomination, and she is touring her Sugar and Booze holiday show.
Other related resources
get this episode’s free download
Read full transcript
Tamsen Fadal: Ana, it's great to see you.
Ana Gasteyer: You too.
Tamsen Fadal: Now that we've already shared beauty secrets. Well, I'm so excited for you for where you are right now in this time in life. It feels like an amazing time.
Ana Gasteyer: It is. It's the best.
Tamsen Fadal: From Broadway, Tony nomination, traveling show. I'm just watching you everywhere.
Ana Gasteyer: Yeah, I so I I made this Christmas album holiday album I should say seven years ago cuz it's really a very secular. We call it seasonal secular favorites. I made it seven years ago, and I've had this career that's always kind of circled the holidays for some reason, with the Sweaty Balls on SNL and the, you know, the like Martha Stewart's Topless Christmas and. And then I wrote this Christmas parody movie, the Hallmark movie, with my friend Rachel Dratch. And anyway, when I did the album I, I was really just um I've, I've sung for a living and I've done comedy for a living for a very long time, they've often been very separate. So, um I had this like Broadway career and then on the side, like many Broadway performers, I would perform, you know, and people would ask me to cabarets or whatever to come in and do a little supper club performance.
But especially around the holidays, there's this throwback vibe that is very comfortable for me, that I I like. I'm very tradition-oriented, but it you can still be a little bit cheeky and people don't sort of mind the like the throwback equality. And I love the American Yeah, they love it. So, I love the American Songbook and I love holiday music. And so this holiday tour has just turned into something almost accidentally now that we do every year and it grows and grows. This is the biggest year we'll be touring. I'm doing two symphony performances, do some phonic performances, and then lots of small clubs, which is where I really like to um shine. So, yeah, I wouldn't have like anticipated it after this crazy Broadway year. Um it sort of didn't stop, but uh but I'm excited that it's sort of, you know, bookending what what has been a pretty amazing 59th year.
Tamsen Fadal: A very amazing 59th year. This is Sugar and Booze, right, that we're talking about? Okay. Yeah, so what is Sugar and Booze? Why did why did you come up with Sugar and Booze? I mean, I guess it's what every single household is doing, so I'm just answering my own question.
Ana Gasteyer: Yeah, I literally I came to you know, when we were when we were putting together the collection, we wanted a holiday album that would you could kind of throw on with your like Ella Fitzgerald and your Frank Sinatra and just have it in the rotation of the classic holiday album and not feel overly modern or overly throwbacky. So, um I wanted something you can make cocktails to, decorate the tree, bake to, have it on at a Christmas party. And um I do feel like increasingly, I mean, you know, the last 10 years have been very fraught as you know, politically in our country and culturally. And um you know, I love touring the Midwest. I love touring the South. I like being I like getting out into the amongst the fan base and performing. So, I say that because I think the holidays are really one of the only times left that you can do that.
There's not that many common denominators in a really authentic way. Even if you're not a majorly religious person, which I'm not, I still love the of it. I still love the fact that almost all of American culture sort of slows down for a minute, celebrates, lets it rip, you know. It's a time Yeah, like it's the one time of year you have your office party, you have your family party, you have you I love getting Christmas cards and seeing pictures of people's kids and how much older they've gotten and just sort of you're keeping I don't know. There's like a reset that happens in December. So um sugar and booze is kind of the way that we let it rip. And that's what the song is about. I wrote the title track. Um we wanted to write originals in in addition to as I said, like favorites.
I mean, yeah, we've got Sleigh Ride on the album and we've got you know, I've got My Love to Keep Me Warm and there's so many great American song um classics that are part of the holiday canon. So
Tamsen Fadal: What makes you say yes to things these days?
Ana Gasteyer: It's really easy. It's uh it's pretty much just joy. If it sparks or generates joy, which is so corny, but
Tamsen Fadal: I don't think it's corny though. I think that I think you have to make decisions based on something, right?
Ana Gasteyer: Yeah, it's interesting because my youngest went to college last in September and um you know, I've it's funny because you would think, well, now's the time to do the thing that's the real pain in the ass, but um because I I can be away, but my reflection was back on how many things I did because I had to when I was raising kids, you know, just to whatever, save up for college tuition or keep the household afloat or things I felt like I had to, the fear of the career drying up, like all those drivers inside of us. Now I feel like I'm doing them because I want to be doing them more and more and more. I would not have thought I would do a Broadway show my son's senior year in high school. I was really reticent to to do a Broadway show because I know the level of commitment required, even though it's in New York City and I'm home theoretically in my own bed every night, you know, you're you're gone every night. So
Tamsen Fadal: It's eight shows a week.
Ana Gasteyer: Eight shows a week.
Tamsen Fadal: It can be It's a brutal schedule.
Ana Gasteyer: Yeah, but my son himself actually was the one that was like, you have to do this. It's a really funny show. It's you're going to want to do it. You love being on Broadway. And both of my kids have reflected to me, really interesting, that I'm really happy when I'm in that musical theater routine. So there's something very physical and rigorous about it that's exhausting, but also really nice cuz there's just a routine to it that's um you know. And also like honestly, people who film things for a living fly away a lot. So I'd much rather be on Broadway than than flying back and forth to LA twice a week or whatever, you know.
Tamsen Fadal: I mean walking into Schmigadoon eight times a week can make you smile.
Ana Gasteyer: Yeah, the set is joyous. I mean that that was a tremendously happy experience um for a million reasons. I mean Cinco Paul's a wonderful leader. Chris Gattelli's the director. It was not a fraught creative process because weirdly they developed the television show and then they'd done it out of town. So it wasn't like sometimes you're in previews on Broadway and you know you're getting massive changes every day and songs are being rewritten and things like that, which is interesting but challenging. Um and then the cast was just insane. There were 120 Broadway credits across our ensemble. Our It was the most experienced Broadway ensemble, which would just makes for deeply grown-up professional colleagues. Um there was no drama.
Tamsen Fadal: Fun on that stage. Yeah.
Ana Gasteyer: We had so much fun. Yeah, we had to have fun because it's hard. If it's it's too hard. It's 2 hours and 40 minutes a show eight times a week, you know it's a physical demand. Costumes are heavy. It seems easy when you're doing it, but it day by day is a very physically demanding job.
Tamsen Fadal: Anything you're doing eight times a week is is demanding on top of what what you were doing all the time. I I want to go back to what you said like you know the the fear of career drying up and your your son knowing that that was a really special place for you being on the stage. I think all of us can I think I, I can especially, but I think all of us can understand that feeling of those fears of the 20s and the 30s and even the 40s, of like relevance and, and feeling like if I don't keep going at full speed, then I'm going to be left behind, right? That's the scariest thing. At 59, did you ever think that that' s what this year was going to look like? Cuz I'm 55 right now, going to be 56. I could never have imagined what I would be doing right now.
Ana Gasteyer: I do think there's like this you know settling that happens and I mean that in a positive way, settling in, like landing in your feet. Um, you know, I don't know if it's hormone replacement therapy or like, you know, coming to the other side of of menopause or or what that question is. For me, it's really felt like I've Yeah, I I I look back at my 20s. My my daughter's 24, so she's launching a a decade I would never ever want to relive in my life. I mean and I look back at Saturday night and I was in fact I was looking through an old press box. So there's obviously like cultural context in this. I I was doing some organizing. Sorry, I'm all over the place, but
Tamsen Fadal: I want to hear this cuz I I think it's fascinating. But I feel the same way. I wouldn't have gone back to my 20s either, so
Ana Gasteyer: It's hard. You don't know where you're going necessarily. It's all I mean it's optimistic and it's there's a lot of potential there, but I think it it's it's so uncertain all of it, you know. Um, I was looking at some of these old press clippings and there was a an an article someone had clipped that was about my pregnancy on Saturday Night Live, which was the first female like the first pregnancy, cast member pregnancy, um obviously female in that setting. I literally I I, It was in writing that I had been so nervous I was going to get fired if they discovered, so I had hid the pregnancy for five and a half months, which in retrospect is like, it's so amazing cuz things worked out and they, everything was fine and I was pregnant and I had my daughter. And you know, people went on Maya Rudolph and Amy Poehler and and Tina Fey all went on to have babies, you know, um, and pregnancies on the show.
But my daughter was looking she was like, was that a thing? Which is so funny because culturally you just forget like the boat turns so slowly. It's like we're all driving our own big cruise ship and as we slowly turn then you look back and whatever that was 25 years ago and yeah, that was a thing. That was really a thing. Like I thought, oh boy, I could probably lose my job. I should hide this, you know. So not because of any overt you know, no one had said that out loud, but just the way that cultures and workplaces have changed in the last couple of decades. So what did I bring this up to say is that I I think so many things like that have just clicked more and more into my organic form if that makes sense. Um, that wasn't really exactly. I remember why I brought it up.
Tamsen Fadal: No, but but what we're talking about that that generation and like at 20, you're just said your daughter's turning 24, right? I mean just it's a totally different time from from the 24 that you or I experienced. I mean I think about I had a news career for 30 years and I felt the same way. I was I I was like I don't know when the right time is to ever do something like that because I'm scared that I won't be able to move ahead faster, quicker quicker than the other one, you know?
Ana Gasteyer: Our generation definitely had outside forces at play. I mean every generation does, but you know, I think that that was real for us, this sort of sense that the clock was running out. I mean you whatever you look at the Golden Girls were like 58 or something insane. You know, like if you were like yeah, Norma Desmond was in her early 60s and that to me I just think the number has really changed in terms of what it is for people. I don't I don't I don't anticipate stopping working for a very long time. And I'm not afraid of my age in that regard. I'm actually relieved because I feel less um I feel I just feel like I know myself better. I feel like I know what I'm good at. I know what I'm bad at, which is really satisfying. Like you know, when people like you should really try drama.
I'm like you don't need to see me drama. It's it's it's fine. Like you know, I I'm I'm happy to be doing what I do.
Tamsen Fadal: You're settled in your in your in your shoes in your role and who and who you are and what you can bring to the table. How did SNL make room for that then? Because I I cuz you were the first. I didn't realize that. I didn't realize you were the first but before Amy and Tina and everybody.
Ana Gasteyer: Um, how did they make room for my pregnancy? Um, I mean like many things we didn't wasn't really we I I told Lauren he was nice about it and you know, we we we wrote around it. I mean I I hid it very well for a long time and then we eventually wrote a couple of funny sketches where I was pregnant, but largely um yeah, our 90s girls were real heads down and do the job. You know, I started the show in '96. I didn't we it was a very trail blazed time at the show, but there was no particular agenda to that end. I mean I I didn't go in there thinking I'm going to trailblaze. I just worked really hard and and there were some writers there that really supported that um some male writers, you know, and
Tamsen Fadal: That's what trailblazers do, though. They don't know they're trailblazing
Ana Gasteyer: Yeah, I mean I think we just we just we just started to have huge success. Molly Shannon, Cheri Oteri, and me started to have on-air success and that's ultimately what what just once once you have hits on the air it's it's it becomes easier to navigate.
Tamsen Fadal: When you look back at that and and look at how each one of you have come to to where you are today, I mean you were young you were young girls, you were young women at the time, and to see where you are in this in this career of of Hollywood or top-rated podcast or, you know, writing films and movies and uh Broadway, what it what does it look like through all those years? Cuz I think that those relationships and those friendships through all those years are really something special.
Ana Gasteyer: I'm closer with the generation that the kind of came at the back end of my cuz I I was straddled two generations at SNL. Um so I spend really consistent time with, you know, Dratch and I wrote a movie together and we all did that wine country movie together and people like and Maya and Dratch have both done um Broadway. Rachel's done Broadway a lot. So we have a lot in common in terms of that. I don't know. I just think what again, this is like a wisdom thing, but I think as you it's a relief to realize like as we've gotten older, everyone there's room for everybody. There's room that we've all had very different careers actually. If we if you really look at the things where people have Sure, we've all had we've all had successes that other people would consider, you know, traditionally um meaningful.
But um you know, I've I've spent a lot of my career singing. I mean a lot, more than people know. You know, I'm on three original Broadway cast recordings. I have two recordings of my own. I You know, that I've performed in a lot of live television musicals. Um again, it's sort of pre-social media a lot of it or maybe I'm just bad at social media, but people don't know about it. Um but it's but it's its own thing. Like I think everybody's had their own Amy and Tina obviously have enormous success producing and developing and writing um themselves for themselves and for other people. So everybody kind of has had these It's cool to see like what pocket people um comfortably fall into.
Tamsen Fadal: Well, I mean you fall into two very big ones and I think a lot of people when you run SNL, a lot of people were very surprised when you when you they heard your voice you belting out Broadway for the the first time. I mean
Ana Gasteyer: Are still surprised. I mean I I'm It's hilarious to me. A lot of people just don't know. I I I You know, it's fine, but like they they
Tamsen Fadal: They're going to know after this.
Ana Gasteyer: Maybe they will. I mean, a lot of people I would... I'm... Again, there's whole generations that didn't grow up watching me on SNL. But who... who... who I was sang at my daughter's friend is an influencer, and they asked me to do a little song at their Joe's Pub show the other day, and I sang, and then somebody came up and, like, "I didn't realize that you sang." You know, so it's it's Uh it's just like a um a secret party trick that matters a lot to me, you know.
Tamsen Fadal: A good party
Ana Gasteyer: Yeah, thanks.
Tamsen Fadal: It's a very good party trick.
Ana Gasteyer: I worked very hard at it.
Tamsen Fadal: I love it.
Ana Gasteyer: I mean, I love it because it's my first calling. You know, like I said, I'm not religious, but if I were, that would be the thing You know, I think about it all the time. It's like people who are athletes or something like that. It's something that I got from somewhere that that's not really about me. I have trained and I have worked, but it's bigger than me and I feel like I'm so glad that I didn't let it go to waste, you know?
Tamsen Fadal: No, and your son seeing that tells you everything about where you're supposed to be. Your son seeing that that's that's the moment that you know you feel very very at peace or very very happy. Um you know, so I want to talk a little bit about being a woman in comedy because SNL, you know, it's just like so incredible and then there's Mean Girls and there's you know, it goes on and on and on. What what is the generation Is it interesting to you that this generation right now is constantly looking back at those movies and like in love with all those nostalgic movies of Mean Girls and this everything I I find it fascinating.
Ana Gasteyer: I mean, I don't. I think it's like you you look towards your you know, ancestors. I mean, I watched Carol Burnett and and Lily Tomlin and yeah, I mean, that's I honestly would not have even thought Saturday Night Live was an option if my particular college era of comedian was not Nora Dunn and Jan Hooks. So, you know, I I it just wasn't like yeah. So I was doing improv in in college and those were the ladies on SNL. So it probably planted a seed way back there that I didn't never think you know, I don't know if this is like distinctly female, but I was never like, I'm going to go be on Saturday Night Live. Like that wasn't even like in my
Tamsen Fadal: It wasn't?
Ana Gasteyer: No, I think it was back there like, wouldn't it be cool if? But I don't think I ever I I never stated the goal like that. Mm-mm.
Tamsen Fadal: How did you discover that comedy and where did it begin? Where did it begin like that? Not just interest, but I feel like comedians are fearless and I I do from me as somebody who's not I you know, I'm a journalist, so I I don't have that part of me. And I look and I'm like, oh my gosh, you must be so fearless. Do you feel that? And has it changed with time?
Ana Gasteyer: I don't know how fearless I am. I feel like I'm I I've always cared about I mean, the sort of my dirty little secret, or it's not even dirty, like about comedy is just just about telling the truth. And and often there's just a lot of human behavior that people that's artificial. And we do it to save face, and we do it because we're embarrassed, and we do it because of protocol, and we do it. You know, and there's different versions of that, and it can be really um not funny, obviously. But um I think yeah, exactly. But I think calling things out is is good for people. I think airing dirty laundry is good for people. I think it's I think it's helpful to I just I don't know. I think I've always wanted to know what the truth is. And so that's I don't know.
It's some not to get too intellectual about it, but a lot of my characters are not are pretty like blind. They They have a lot of blinders on, and I think there's something to me very funny about people not addressing the reality of the situation, you know?
Tamsen Fadal: You know, you could have said I'm going to stick with SNL and have be defined by that for your career. And you said nope, there's like so much more. Um how did you make that decision? And was that was that just saying yes to the things that bring you joy?
Ana Gasteyer: No, I was at that age. Um
Tamsen Fadal: What was the age, actually?
Ana Gasteyer: I was 35 cuz I'd had Frances, my daughter. Yeah. Um I'd been there six years. I really felt like I had done what I set out to do. I was really proud of the work that I did. I didn't want to have, like, in my mind, I didn't want it to be just diminishing returns and not being. And I didn't want to like, I knew that parenting was going to... was I didn't know anybody who had children. Or, you know, I was it was kind of like a whole different world than I'd come from. So um yeah, I think I was just ready to go figure out what that next that next move was. I mean, at times I wish I'd stayed longer, but it's it's a hugely consuming job. I mean, it's not, you know, nine months a year, it's you go completely underwater.
You know, even when I go back to visit, it's like I was thinking, oh no, this time I'm going to answer my phone calls, you know.
Tamsen Fadal: Boundaries this time.
Ana Gasteyer: But it's always it's Monday night, and the next thing you know, it's Saturday morning, and you've got like a 20 phone calls that you have to reply to, and you know, it's just very consuming because it's live and you're creating it and it's in real time and it's super creatively fulfilling and, and you know, you're preoccupied. So I just didn't know I honestly just didn't know. Not even like I didn't know. Like I didn't know how to do it with with a family. So, you know, people have definitely figured out how to do that. But so I just decided that I wanted and I wanted to dig a little deeper. I wanted to move past Sketch kind of as a not past Sketch. I love the form of Sketch, but like to see what it would feel like to play a character all the time.
I love doing I I I feel lucky because I love doing Broadway. I love half hour comedy. I love playing the same person once a week. It's a great schedule. Um I like being on ensembles, you know. I like writing. So there's there were just there's just a lot to do and make. It's like I feel like the only thing I'm worried about is running out of time. I still I have a list as long as my arm of things I'm trying to get done right now, you know.
Tamsen Fadal: Your list? I want to hear some of them.
Ana Gasteyer: Well, I started a little production company with my friend Danielle who produced A Clüsterfünke Christmas, the holiday parody that Dratch and I did. Um that's on Paramount Plus this holiday season. It's a Hallmark parody. But we have a couple of TV shows. We have a fantastic reality show holiday. We everything there's a lot of things that over she's she's involved with producing September Davis. So there's a lot of crossover between um I would say where you know, comedy and music and and Christmas intersect.
Tamsen Fadal: Yeah, but that's that's a great intersection.
Ana Gasteyer: And I'm also just genuinely interested in kind of the new new world.
Tamsen Fadal: Things have changed so much and there's so many different ways to present it and that opens you, I'm assuming, to so many different audiences from all generations.
Ana Gasteyer: Yeah, I mean it's overwhelming, but I'm super interested in it. I basically just need a benefactor. So if anybody wants to be my benefactor, please let me know.
Tamsen Fadal: There could be somebody listening and we'll have a
Ana Gasteyer: We have these like short-form ideas and we have I have a YouTube channel and we have holiday ideas and all these things, but one of the problems I think in the industry right now is that there's still, you know, seven guys holding the purse strings. So it's like figuring out how to get to the next
Tamsen Fadal: I know. Do you think we're ever going to get past that? I mean I feel like we I feel like we have such incredible women like yourself that have been pushing through all of those places, but you still feel like that's that is what's going on at the end of the day.
Ana Gasteyer: I'm telling you I have 100 things to make. I just need And also, by the way, because I'm a woman, I'm happy to make them for like $5.
Tamsen Fadal: I I'll do them for three sometimes. Yeah, I I totally understand that. Okay, I'm going to bring this up to you because I was I was just thinking about it as you're talking. I have noticed I have noticed all of a sudden and maybe this is the men thing or maybe I started talking about menopause, perimenopause six years ago. I'm seeing it kind of tossed into every single show or TV show. Like I was watching a spy show the other day and the the spy's like and I might be menopausal. I'm like you're a perimenopausal spy now? Like are you seeing that that happens sometimes? A perimenopausal spy.
Ana Gasteyer: It's so funny that you say that because there's a lot of like male content creators about their wives perimenopause. That's so funny. I mean and they they make me laugh, by the way, but it's still like yeah, it's so funny.
Tamsen Fadal: Of tossed in there. Like I don't have I'm like I don't know how you're putting it in there, but we're going to put the word menopause and hot flash in there somewhere.
Ana Gasteyer: And it's very in.
Tamsen Fadal: It's very in. Menopause is very very in.
Ana Gasteyer: Very in. Well, if you want to do that with me, I'll do it for a dollar, I swear. Okay.
Tamsen Fadal: Is there something out there you no longer feel the need to prove? I'm wondering about that because I feel like now when you say you're doing things for joy, and I feel like no matter what profession women are in, um I don't even know if it's a second act or a third act. I don't know what act we're in at this point, but I do feel like I don't have to prove anything to anybody else. I'm not so worried about if somebody else likes it, but I am you know I'm on that other side of 50 or menopause, or whatever you want it to be, where there's not tons of time left; but I want to make sure that I do everything I can that I've wanted to do.
Ana Gasteyer: Yeah. I think about it all the time. Um I'm not sure I'm going to answer your question with like a specific exactly, but um I do. I think it's like a it's like I sometimes I feel like Alexander Hamilton like you know, like the Lin-Manuel like I got you know, I'm running out of time. Like I got to get it all done, you know. Um and then you know, I feel that way. And then other times I think but conversely like I just had my 30th wedding anniversary, and I'm like
Tamsen Fadal: Anniversary.
Ana Gasteyer: Thank you. And I'm like we we a lot of what's successful about us we like we're great workaholics and we both work really well in our like silos and it's we get we understand that. And I was said to my husband on our anniversary dinner, I was like, we need to like plan more time together. Like, I'm just like keenly aware that it's you know, I mean, it might be 25 30 years if we're lucky, you know? So, um just making sure that all of that I think I just I think just dialing in Marty Short has this thing about um like a I always imagine like a little like preschool clock like you know, with a little like pipe cleaners. It's literally like a third like family work family work friends, family work friends, family work friends. And like this was a year I barely saw friends.
I barely even talked to friends. I was so I mean, save for a few text chains and you know, my workplaces are very social, so they're really fun. But like I there are lots of people with whom I feel like I am out of touch, you know? So spending a little bit of time just like re reconnecting, you know? And you're not asked that that just not answering your question at all, except that I think it just makes me like
Tamsen Fadal: But it is. It's appreciation of what's left.
Ana Gasteyer: Yeah, just dialing in like dialing in on that's what I mean like picking work and jobs that have frankly friends involved or people that I like or people that I want to mentor um super life's too short committee, you know? In terms of like no dicks. Um really like no dicks. I don't want to work with any dicks anymore. And if people have got drama like it's okay like go work it out, that's okay. I don't you know? And then just being really available to my friends and my husband and my kids, you know?
Tamsen Fadal: I love that in all in all ways. Um so both your kids are gone to college or are out of the house?
Ana Gasteyer: Now, but she's out of college. Yeah.
Tamsen Fadal: All right. Well, so that's good.
Ana Gasteyer: Yeah, it's not 100% emptiness yet.
Tamsen Fadal: It's it's halfway empty I suppose.
Ana Gasteyer: Yeah, it's cool cuz she's an adult, so she's like
Tamsen Fadal: That's great.
Ana Gasteyer: Doesn't require much from us, but she's around, which is nice.
Tamsen Fadal: Yeah, but that's really nice. That's nice to be able to see see that her especially cuz it's the you know, it's your daughter seeing her in in that age and where you were. Let let's go into a little bit about Broadway and the Tony nomination and what you were doing at the time because I feel like that's a really pivotal, incredible, congratulations moment. Um, is it Have you been in six shows or more on Broadway? How many shows? Six This was This was six.
Ana Gasteyer: Yeah, this was number six.
Tamsen Fadal: What was that like? Where were you when you got the nomination? How does
Ana Gasteyer: The first thing in the morning, so you're always in bed cuz they announced them at like I don't know. 7:30 in the morning or something horrible. It was the day after my birthday, so I was kind of like I I was fine. I mean, I was like I I I I felt like the show was I really wanted the show to be nominated and it's funny now that they won Best Musical, but you know, when you're in the middle of it, you're like it's not the cool show. It's like the big happy Broadway show, but it's not like you know,
Tamsen Fadal: Yeah, I know.
Ana Gasteyer: Lost Lost Boys was cool and everybody was like, oh, I think the Lost Boys is going to win, you know, whatever. Um, so I was really invested in that and Cinco Paul just couldn't be a nicer person or harder worker. So I And Chris Gattelli, I really wanted him to get the nomination too. So it was thrilling, you know? And then Dratch is just a great friend. She was She was really wanting me to get nominated. She really felt um, she was just very generous about that. She She called me like the second it happened. You know, she actually got nominated first cuz it's alphabetical.
Tamsen Fadal: Oh, wow. Okay. Yeah, yeah, yeah.
Ana Gasteyer: To say I'm watching. I you're I I think you're going to get nominated and I was like, I don't think I am. And then and then she got nominated. And then um, you know,
Tamsen Fadal: Imagine her reaction.
Ana Gasteyer: She was screaming. Yeah, she called me. She couldn't believe it. So But it's also fun cuz it's a lot of work, Tony nominations, I'm sure you know from Paul, like it's it's a very short window and unlike, you know, the Emmys or Oscars or whatever you have I mean, they're all short, but this is like um, you've got whatever, a month and you there are these like specific events that you have to attend with voters in addition to, you know, PR and then you're doing the show every night. So it's it's definitely like a full-time job.
Tamsen Fadal: Oh, there's no break in between there at all. You've got the show that you're doing. How many cities are you going to be touring now? For Sugar and Boost.
Ana Gasteyer: We're doing 15 cities. We're doing a week We're leaving on Friday, so we'll have a week prior to Thanksgiving, which, you know, some people get very uptight about um, cuz they don't know how they feel about their holiday, but I'm like they have I I you know, Walgreens had their decorations out.
Tamsen Fadal: Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. They're sugar and booze. You'll be fine.
Ana Gasteyer: I made my IKEA run last night. My husband's like, why are you doing IKEA? It's not even Thanksgiving. I was like, because the really good wrapping paper is going to be gone. Trust me. So that's what I do. Every year I make my little run. I get my my IKEA has got great holiday stuff. So
Tamsen Fadal: Oh, I didn't even know that. Okay.
Ana Gasteyer: Like for wrapping and decorating and stuff like that, I always try to hit their It's always cute and Scandinavian and whatever. So that'll be next week next week. This weekend we'll be in Minneapolis. Minneapolis, Chicago, East Lansing, Michigan where my brother teaches at Michigan State University. It's my second time there. Um I always play Chicago. Evanston, which is incredible, where I went to college. And then we'll be doing Toledo, Ohio and Indianapolis, the Cabaret, which is really a lovely venue as well. And then um come home, make turkey. Already ordered it. I ordered a pie at my favorite place and then I'll figure out the rest. Um and then we'll turn around and leave. We do a quick We do an East Coast run. Then we do Philly, New York City here at the Town Hall, which is a beautiful venue. That's December 4th.
Tamsen Fadal: That's my birthday.
Ana Gasteyer: Hey, happy birthday. Um come celebrate with us. Um we'll bring We'll give you presents. And then um we're doing DC, Rhode Island, Sarasota,
Tamsen Fadal: Okay.
Ana Gasteyer: Hyannis, a bunch of East Coast cities, Long Island. And then we'll go out to California to close out in uh I'm doing the Long Beach Symphony and then Rancho Cucamonga and Los Angeles with Blue Note Jazz Club.
Tamsen Fadal: It's really incredible.
Ana Gasteyer: It's beautiful. And then we'll end My very last show is at the St. Louis Symphony, which will be nice. It'll just be me, but it'll be I mean there's nothing more incredible than singing with the Symphony.
Tamsen Fadal: That's incredible.
Ana Gasteyer: It's very very magical. And it gives you the chance to wear a slightly uh fancier outfit.
Tamsen Fadal: I like that. Glitter? I don't know. Sequins?
Ana Gasteyer: I don't know. Symphony is like like
Tamsen Fadal: Oh, it's classy. I'm sorry you have to be elegant. I'm sorry. Okay.
Ana Gasteyer: Oh, believe me. I do a lot of glitter on stage. We keep it nice and mirror ball happy cuz it's a It's my show's really a holiday party so we've got a full horn section. We've got, you know, um Glockenspiels, we've got comedy instruments, everything you can.
Tamsen Fadal: What's up for next year? Do you know what you want to do?
Ana Gasteyer: Next year I'm going to record some new Christmas music um right out of the gate which I'm really excited about cuz it has been seven years and it's time for part two. And then um we're pitching a bunch of shows. We'll see what happens after that.
Tamsen Fadal: I love it. I I love the fact that um any young women that are watching us today I I couldn't I couldn't even imagine 55 or 60 or any any of these years and I guess I I look at everything you're doing and that we're all doing in this this decade and it's it's pretty damn incredible. Do you step back and look at that?
Ana Gasteyer: Yeah, it's great. It's it's it's um it's great. It's it's just great to like I said to turn off a little bit of the worry. I mean the worry is still there. You still want to be good. You still want people to like your shows. You still want to be, you know, audience friendly. I just mean to um the sort of being chased by lions survival fear. Like that that part I feel like has dissipated. Could just be hormone replacement therapy or Prozac or both.
Tamsen Fadal: Both of those work. My my Lexapro works too. I think both work.
Ana Gasteyer: And what it does work for me cuz I I started Prozac during perimenopause and what it what it really helps me to do is to step back and and just see the anxiety is slightly further away from me than it was, you know. When I when I really talk about my 20s, 30s, 40s anxiety it was like, as my friend Steven and I say, a metallic taste in the back of mouth. Like just that that fight or flight, cortisol, constant, you know, being chased by lions and, you know, like like your body thinks that you're being chased by a lion and I it's kind of just what I like about being in my 50s is feeling like there's no lion. Like these are just choices. It it sometimes things work out, sometimes they don't. Sometimes you're good in stuff, sometimes you're bad. You know, it's it's it's okay. Like the world's not going to end, you know?
Tamsen Fadal: I so appreciate that. I I know I told somebody before I was like, I live in New York City, so if you slow down, someone will just come from behind and just run you over. Like that's how I always felt. I always felt like I was like in a high speed chase on the sidewalk just with myself and I didn't really understand it.
Ana Gasteyer: I mean, there's enough to be worried about, right? Like so many of us are we have kids, we have so I think you just get a little bit of wisdom. I mean, not everybody has kids, but it it you you reach this point where you're just like, I know what a really bad day usually by 50 you really know what a terrible day looks like and if most of them aren't like that, then we're winning.
Tamsen Fadal: It's pretty damn good. It's pretty damn good. Does that help with your humor and help with being funny and help with how you see things differently? Are you do you do you think what you what you talk about on stage now versus maybe what you did at 30? I mean, there's a whole different perspective, obviously. You have so much more wisdom, but
Ana Gasteyer: A great question. No, I think if anything I'm probably less funny, but I no, I mean, but I do believe in some of that stuff of like you do have to kind of refill your cup and and be ready to yeah, I don't know. Like lately I've just been enjoying making dinner and sleeping late and trying that's like my prep, you know? We'll see what because it was a lot of not doing that this year. So hopefully I'll start to find the comedy and things again.
Tamsen Fadal: I can't wait to see what's next. Thank you so much. You're wonderful.
Ana Gasteyer: Thank you
medical disclaimer:
The information provided in this podcast is for educational and informational purposes only and is not intended as medical advice. Always consult with a qualified healthcare professional regarding any medical concerns or treatment options. The views expressed by guests are their own and do not necessarily reflect those of The Tamsen Show.






