Episode Description
Women learn early which parts of themselves make other people comfortable. After enough years, that performance can begin to feel like our identity, and the intuition underneath it goes quiet.
Dr. Ellen Vora spent much of her life inside that worldview. A Yale- and Columbia-trained psychiatrist, she built her life around science and skepticism. Then, during an acupuncture treatment, Ellen received a message she couldn’t explain away, and it opened a question her training couldn’t answer: When someone dies, does the relationship actually end? That experience forced her to reconsider what she believed about grief, intuition, and the limits of what we can prove.
Today, Ellen shares the full story behind her new book, Season of the Witch: A Psychiatrist’s Case for Magic, and why women are taught to give up essential parts of themselves in order to be taken seriously. She argues that we’ve been missing something, and the way back starts in the body.
What you’ll learn
- How being agreeable and low-maintenance can become a form of self-abandonment
- Why women have been taught to distrust their intuition
- How to distinguish intuition from anxiety, and the ways the body signals yes and no
- Why menopause can represent a rebirth rather than a disappearance
- What grief can teach us about continuing relationships with the people we have lost
- Why the “witch” archetype has always been connected to women who are no longer easily controlled
- Simple ways to become more receptive to meaning, guidance, and magic in everyday life
This is a conversation about returning to the parts of ourselves we learned to suppress, and letting life become a little more mysterious and alive.
Timestamps
0:00 Introduction to Dr. Ellen Vora
4:40 Why Women Were Taught to Doubt Their Intuition
6:34 The “Chill Girl” Habit That Makes Women Abandon Their Needs
8:40 How Grief Opened the Door to Spirituality
17:36 What Does “Magic” Actually Mean?
25:16 How to Tell Intuition From Anxiety
28:40 5 Practices to Reconnect With Your Inner Power
32:38 Why Postmenopausal Women Hold a Different Kind of Power
41:03 Why Women Need to Stop Feeling Guilty About Being “Selfish”
54:11 The Unexpected Message From Her Mother
Share with a Friend
If you liked this episode, listen to these episodes
guest appearing in this episode
Dr. Ellen Vora
Dr. Ellen Vora is a Yale- and Columbia-trained holistic psychiatrist, acupuncturist, and author of The Anatomy of Anxiety and Season of the Witch: A Psychiatrist's Case for Magic. She joins Tamsen on The Tamsen Show to explore why women are conditioned to distrust their intuition and how reconnecting with your body restores inner clarity.

Dr. Vora's new book
Season of the Witch: A Psychiatrist's Case for Magic
by Ellen Vora, MD
A Yale- and Columbia-trained psychiatrist, Dr. Vora spent years trusting only what she could measure, until a shattering loss pushed her to reconsider. In Season of the Witch, she shares five practices for reclaiming the intuition modern life trains women to dismiss, from embodiment and presence to being open to mystery. With Tamsen, she explains how to tell intuition apart from anxiety and why menopause can be a rebirth rather than a disappearance.
Get the book
Get Dr. Vora's first book, The Anatomy of Anxiety: Understanding and Overcoming the Body's Fear Response
Visit Dr. Vora's website
Other related resources
- Study Listening to Your Heart: How Interoception Shapes Emotion Experience and Intuitive Decision Making Dunn et al., Psychological Science, 2010. How body signals guide gut-level decisions.
- Study Knowing your own heart: Distinguishing interoceptive accuracy from interoceptive awareness Garfinkel et al., Biological Psychology, 2015. Sensing the body versus believing you sense it.
- Study Interoception in anxiety and depression Paulus & Stein, Brain Structure and Function, 2010. Why anxiety can distort the body's signals.
- Study Continuing Bonds in Bereavement: An Attachment Theory Based Perspective Field, Gao & Paderna, Death Studies, 2005. Staying connected to people we have lost.
- Study Religiosity and Major Depression in Adults at High Risk: A Ten-Year Prospective Study Miller et al., American Journal of Psychiatry, 2012. How a sense of spiritual meaning relates to depression risk.
- Study Grandmothering, menopause, and the evolution of human life histories Hawkes et al., PNAS, 1998. Why life after menopause may be a strength, not an ending.
get this episode’s free download
Read full transcript
I think of one patient, she lost her father. Sometimes she would feel his presence, but she would quickly backpedal from that and say, "I know that's foolish. I don't believe in woo-woo. That's not real." Why rush to doubt it? The inexplicable, the uncanny, the wink from the universe that we don't really know the whole story.
Were you nervous about a book that had psychiatrist and witch on it?
I probably should be.
Are there things science simply can't explain? Leading psychiatrist Dr. Ellen Vora has spent her career rooted in science and skepticism. Now, she's making the case for intuition, spirituality, and even magic. Before we start, I have to share something cuz I am so excited. The Tamsen Show is nominated for seven Signal Awards, basically the Emmys of podcasting, and we would not be here without this community. You watch, you listen, you share these conversations, and you have truly helped us build this show into what it is. So, thank you, truly. Now, I'm asking for one more thing. Please vote for us. It literally takes 1 minute, and make sure you confirm your email after you vote so it counts. The link is right in the description.
Thank you so much. It would mean so much to me.
Ellen, it's so good to see you.
Tamsen, it's so good to see you.
We have a history together in the women's health space, but today we're talking about something a little bit different, which is exciting, which is your new book. The title, Season of the Witch, and I think that people might see the title and assume you've always been very comfortable with spirituality and intuition, but that's not really the case. A lot of your life you were a skeptic.
Mhm.
Yeah, no, quite the contrary. In a way, I'm the preacher who has sinned. Like, I am the witch who was very left-brained and skeptical, and sort of made an identity around not being into woo-woo things.
And science, all science, right?
Yes, right. I was obsessed with science.
And you still are, I assume.
Still love science.
But you've got some add-ons to it. So, who were you before you began believing that there might be more to the reality than what you could actually prove?
I grew up in the suburbs of New York City. What was cool was to be an atheist. We worshipped at the altar of science. We worshipped at the altar of skepticism, and I looked around and perceived this is what the world values as intelligent. The world was telling me be linear and rational and skeptical, and that is what's celebrated. And so, I was like I understood the assignment. I got the memo and was like I can do that. No problem. And I performed that side of myself for decades. And I it served me well. It opened doors. I went through college and med school and psychiatry residency. And really got a lot out of cultivating those strengths, but then over time I did start to appreciate that that's a self-betrayal and a fragmentation because performing that side of yourself requires disavowing the mystical intuitive side.
Well, and it's interesting because you mentioned Dr. Lisa Miller, and she's been on the show. And so, you know, I know that she talks a lot about this and that side. And we do disavow that. We do say like I don't know, that's the woo-woo part. I don't really know what I believe in. So, you went to Yale, trained as a physician at Columbia University, became a psychiatrist. What did education really teach you about which forms of knowledge we consider as I guess legitimate?
Well, you go through medical training and when you're a little budding med student and resident, you're really trying to be taken seriously. You know, you're nervous that you're going to walk into a patient's room and the patient the patient's going to be like, "But you're too young to be my doctor." So, you're really trying to take on that persona. And I was reading the room and understanding that there was a way to be professional, but also to be rigorous in academic medicine. And it is so much reliance on well, here's what the evidence says and this is the data that's going to steer clinical decision-making. And that's the language you speak to be taken seriously, to speak in the right way in that setting.
So, I did that and I slowly started to become aware of the fact that I had other dimensions of my brain that were also guiding clinical decisions, but you don't speak of that.
It wouldn't be acceptable.
Intuition, is that what you would call it?
Intuition, yeah.
Intuition, feeling, a gut feeling, I kind of always knew this, I felt this early on, they're words that we all use. Why has intuition historically been treated as something a lot less legitimate?
I feel like we need to roll up our sleeves
And like get popcorn to really answer that question, but basically, I think it has a lot to do with the fact that women in particular who stand firmly in that knowing and have that conviction were perceived to be a threat to the establishment, to the status quo. Because if a woman has a very strong sense of her conviction, she is not easily dominated, she's not very governable, she's not a very differential wife, she's not a very differential employee. If we have a sense of how to use herbs to practice healing, if we have a sense of how to practice midwifery, that's a threat to at the time an emerging male-dominated medical system, even in a way that it's a sensitive topic to veer out into, but if a woman has a direct relationship to what she might call source, that's a threat to religious institutions.
So, I think when we are really standing in that knowing and that conviction, that threatens so many power systems that really depend on us doubting ourselves.
So, when did you start seeing I guess the qualities that were making you successful separating you from who you truly are or who you knew you were?
That was a process that was very light for me for a long time where I was getting into yoga. So, I would be like, okay, you know, I'm an atheist and I don't like woo-woo things, but I do like chanting om before I exercise. And I think that wore that like a badge?
Yeah, I did. I wanted to be taken seriously. I wanted to be the chill girl, low maintenance, in the boys clubs.
What's the chill girl?
Well, the chill girl is a whole complicated topic because I think that when I was a teenager, I also looked around and saw ways that women were buying respect and admission into the boys clubs. And there were not that many pathways. There weren't that many role models. But one way seemed to be to not be fussy or high maintenance or demand much of anybody, to not inconvenience anybody. And so I was like, I can do that. I'll be chill. And looking back, I recognize now from the moment we hit puberty, there's actually nothing chill about the machinery of the female body. It only gets less chill. But I think that every time I was like, no, I'm good. I don't need a bathroom break on this road trip. Every time I was like, I'm going to just deal with my period in privacy and secret, not inconvenience anybody around me, and not demand more time for rest. All of that was steamrolling over the needs of my body. And I think I paid the price in a lot of ways that I got out of balance with my physical health. But perhaps even more critically, it's a way that we're betraying ourselves, that we're not honoring the worthiness of our bodies to take up the space and the rest that they need.
Well, we go around looking for external permission for everything, right? And trying to make sure that we fit in so many different ways. It's interesting that you were trying so hard to fit into the boys club at such an early age.
Yeah.
That was important to you to be taken seriously or what you perceived to be taken seriously.
I think these are all attempts that we make for safety and survival. That was the pathway I saw was that here's the gender that seems to have more power. And I wanted what I saw.
So let's go forward with where you were. taught to, you know, you were taught to that or you taught yourself to do that, still struggling against what was happening internally. And I think for a lot of women that are listening, they can completely relate with self-abandonment, you know, going along and getting along and trying to like not worry about any of those things and say if everybody around me feels comfortable, then I'll just I'll fit in.
Yeah.
You had something happen to you that I is the unimaginable when you were 6 months pregnant. Can we go back to that time? That's where you open the book and it hit me because I lost my mother at the age of 20 just after my 20th birthday, maybe 3 weeks after the day after Christmas. So, when I opened the book and I read that and I just I can't even imagine the grief though that you were feeling during that time. Can you talk about what happened, where you were, and how this opened a lot of these pathways?
Yeah, and I want to acknowledge the grief that you experienced and we all have these defining crises in our lives. So, I was 6 months pregnant with my daughter and my mom was at the time 68, healthy, active and she passed away suddenly. she had a pulmonary embolism. So, I was thrown into very painful grief. And I think when you're pregnant also, a lot of things are pretty dialed up. All the emotions are even more at the surface. So, I was really thrown into it. And like everyone in a grieving process, I was grappling with those boilerplate questions of grief. Like, what happened? Why did this have to happen? And where is she now? And will I be okay? And will my dad be okay? And one of the questions that kept bumping up against my psyche was does my mom continue to exist in some form or is loss absolute?
Mhm.
And the worldview I had grown up with was that this is a material universe. Death is senseless and random and the end is the end.
Mhm.
And I was fine with my yoga diluted spirituality for a long time that was full of contradictions, but loss has a way of demanding resolution. So, I was no longer comfortable in that maybe space. Kind of felt the need to put my penny down and say, here's what I actually believe. And I really wanted I wanted to choose to believe that my mom's that she continued to exist in some form. Cuz the alternative was untenable at the time. But that was a very awkward fit for me. And I really bristled against the idea that maybe she still exists.
So, what happened? You spent your entire career supporting other people's pain, seeing people go through this, examining grief, looking at this, and now that's where you find yourself. What did your mom's loss disrupt in you and how did it come about?
I think I mean every big Every time life has kicked me in the teeth, I've become a better psychiatrist. And I'm not really asking for more lessons, but I think that it's important for the work that I do. It expands my capacity for empathy. And for me that bristly discomfort shifted this moment when I went to get acupuncture, which was about a week or two after my mom passed away. Good friend of mine saw me stuck struggling, not sleeping, very tender and raw, and she's like, go see Momoko. And I went to see Momoko, and she's an acupuncturist who has some intuitive abilities. And she gave me an acupuncture treatment, and I'm lying on the table, needles placed, my psyche took flight. I was having all these memories from childhood and really visceral memories of my mom sitting at the kitchen table with a bowl of minestrone with a library book and that plastic crinkle sound.
And I was exploring all of those childhood memories. And then at a certain point my reverie just landed on the book that I had been reading at the time, which was 50 Shades of Kale by Drew Ramsey. He's a friend of mine and great book, but I was actually having a fairly low-vibration thought at the time. I was just feeling envy. I was feeling envy of Drew and thinking, "Will I ever write a book? Am I falling behind in my career?" And feeling like ambition was slipping farther and farther away. I'm pregnant, I'm grieving. It just all felt out of reach. That's what I was thinking about when Momoko cleared her throat and interrupted the silence. And she said, "I have a message coming through from your mom, if it's okay to share." And like I'm fumbling over my words.
Can I say this quickly enough? Like, "Yes, please, definitely share it." And she said, "Well, your mom is saying it's time to stop reading books and start writing books."
What did you do? What did you I was in full-body goosebumps. It felt so uncanny.
About somebody else's book. You're thinking about "Should I write a book?"
Mhm.
And my mom was basically saying, "Ahem, Yes. Do it." And it felt like this not only helpful advice, but it also felt like "Does this mean she's here? She's not here in the flesh, and I yearn for that, and it's painful that she's not. That continues to be true. But is she here in some other form? And does that change absolutely everything?"
Was that hard for you with the background and your understanding of psychiatry and science? How difficult was that push-pull for you? Obviously, it was that I want her to be here in some capacity, but my mind and the studies and the years tell me something else.
Yeah, I mean it was I was in like this whole whirlpool swirl of conflicting, contradictory emotions because it was a mismatch for how I'd been raised and the worldview that I identified with, but then I also was yearning for it. Like at the time I was cornering every rabbi, priest, healer I could find and being like, "Tell me what you know. What's real out there?" And so that was in certain ways a contradiction, but it was also a salve. It was also a really comforting thought that she continues to exist in some form. And it at first I tried it on like a jacket. I was like, "Can I navigate my life with the belief that she's still here and I can have an ongoing connection?" And I was clumsy with that at the beginning.
Now I'm 11 years out and that is a moment-to-moment constant companion. That is how I navigate my life. It's what provides guidance, it provides comfort, it certainly softens the ache of grief. But it also it's not just that it relieves pain. It is also access to transcendence. It's also something that makes life more charming and more magical. And that's a main driver for me with writing this book is I just don't want people to miss the magic. And it's not to say I'm here to proselytize any worldview. I don't know what the real truth is. Like none of us actually does. We find out when we die and we go to that room and they give us all the answers and if there is no room, then there's our answer.
I was like, "Is there a room?" We'll find out. But I think that in the time between now and maybe that room, I'm getting comfort from this and I was missing out on it because of a worldview that I had internalized from the culture around me.
So what changed in your grief when you allowed yourself to believe that your relationship with your mother had not ended with her death?
Yeah, I mean it went from a feeling of resistance to reality and really struggling against it to feeling like, "Well, if she can continue to exist, something vastly beyond our comprehension is occurring here. This is weirder, wilder, more magical than we understand." And that feels a little bit like was her death didn't carry some kind of divine timing, something that I'll never understand and I'll always resist, of course, but maybe it has to be so. But also, I used to see her maybe one to two times a month in my early 30s, and now I'm talking to her all day long. And she's with me, she helps me, she witnesses in my mind my daughter growing up. And it's almost like she's more here than ever before.
Do you feel her presence in a way that you could never have imagined you could do that 10 year 20 years ago?
It wasn't on my bingo card 10 or 20 years ago. I were I guess now 10 years ago even is wildly within the span of since I've had this shift, but even though that feels like ancient past. But it's I think I just didn't realize this was on the menu. And that's part of what I want as an aha moment for people is to say if you're truly very rational identified and you know, and many of us are, or many of the most successful people in the room are, I just want people to reopen the case and explore is that rationalism and skepticism truly yours or is that a cultural conditioning that you internalized decades ago?
I know I mean that that hits very deep when you say that because then you do question everything at that point about what you believe, why you believe, and what you want to believe going forward.
Yeah.
So, you call the book The Season of the Witch, A Psychiatrist's Case for Magic. And a lot of people are going to hear the word magic and think of like fantasy and Harry Potter, believing that, you know, we can control thoughts or whatever that happens to us. Can you define what you mean by magic? And why so many of us need it right now?
You and my editor both really want me to answer this question.
I struggled with it.
I'm a journalist, what am I going to say, Ellen?
No, it's what, where, why, it's fair. I mean the inexplicable, the uncanny, the wink from the universe that we don't really know the whole story. And I know I don't mean like Hollywood spells and magic. Nothing against that, but I really mean a very practical daily companion to life, which is that yes, we have to get through this material universe, this earth school, and we have to sit in traffic, and we have to pay our taxes, but maybe there is something else occurring here that I find is a source of guidance, comfort, and transcendence.
Has that helped you as a not only a woman and a mom? Has it helped you as a psychiatrist?
Yeah. I mean it's I dance that I strike a balance between often wishing this for my patients, but never wanting to push that. That's not the purview of a psychiatrist, right? This is I'm not a clergy person. It's really outside of the realm of what I was trained to do. But Lisa Miller's work, we understand the role for even secular spirituality in mental health. Lower rates of depression, lower rates of suicidal ideation. And I'll see sometimes patients that are in a state of moral injury or despair that I suspect would be easier to move through if there was any feeling of there is support, there is guidance. there's meaning to the unfoldings of our lives, which is really different than saying everything happens for a reason.
Not that interested in that spiritual bypass, but more so, here's how things are unfolding. Can we find a way to not be in resistance to that reality, and can we make meaning from how things are unfolding?
How do you help somebody open up to that? If somebody is not you know, does allowing magic I get I guess the question is does allowing magic require believing in mediumship, or can somebody who is a skeptic still understand that and still experience it?
I think there's no rules, and I definitely never want to push this before anybody is ready for it. So, I look for moments of a crack in the facade. I think of one patient who she lost her father when she was two. I'm going to try to leave out any identifying details, but she lost her father when she was two and she had a somewhat fraught relationship with religion. So, she was on the pendulum swing away from it of I don't believe in anything. And but she missed her dad. And sometimes she would feel his presence, but she would quickly backpedal from that and say, "I know that's foolish. I don't believe in woo-woo. That's not real." And so, it was more just offering up like why rush to doubt it?
And can you let yourself feel that and feel the comfort of that and just enjoy it? And do we know we don't know, but maybe it doesn't hurt to feel that ongoing connection with him.
Why are we so I don't know if anyone can answer this, but why are we so quick to go that's not what that can be. I you know, I my mom's Catholic. When I go into a church, I feel like whatever this is that I want to cry every time and I don't know what that is and I think, "Oh, I'm just emotional." And that's where I remember her the most. It could be something completely different, but why are we so quick to push that aside?
Yeah, I mean and I love that. I want to cry anytime something is what I would now call holy, which can be walking into a church or feeling the presence of a mom, but I also think birth is holy, death is holy. And you immediately want to cry. There's this kind of God-tinged tears that come through where it's like, "Okay, we're in the presence of that and it's sublime." But I think we want to rush away from it partly because we perceive the value system of our culture, which tells us that rational left hemispheric linear way of thinking, that's what's intelligent. So, we want to be respected and seen as intelligent. We don't want to be seen as irrational and crazy and a frivolous flaky person. But I think it goes deeper.
I think it has to do with the witch trials where to be associated with that was a threat to our lives. And so, I think even the ways we call women crazy, I think that there's a whole legacy around this. Calling something alternative medicine, we all want to distance ourselves from things that are woo-woo because it either you lose respect and people will roll their eyes or kind of sit back arms crossed or even darker consequences.
So, how do we help women begin hearing themselves in whatever capacity that they want to do that, whether we use the word witch or we use the word intuition, or we use the word magic? Because I guess I think about this, you know, women have spent decades being guided by expectations and by approval and by achievement and other people's needs. How do you quiet that noise and help somebody start hearing themselves again? Where does that begin?
Yeah, so I'm always trying to come at someone, a reader, a patient, and figure out where is there click point for behavioral change. And so, I'm a very like I like the aha moment, so I I'm opening with that proudly, loudly at the beginning of the book. But, some women are so of the mindset of I need to exist in selfless service of others. And I go a lot into the pressures of why and the pressures of likability and how that is even it has to do with our reproductive success. Like this is deeply hardwired evolutionarily in women. But, I also think that sometimes I use that as an entry point because why now with this book? It's some confluence of we're more platformed, more we're more resourced, we have some legal protections, we are having conversations about menopause in a public sphere.
I think that's consequential, but it's also a moment where we don't have the luxury to wait until it's absolutely safe. We the world sits at the precipice of destruction along multiple dimensions, and I think it's the embodied wisdom of witchy women, that understand how to tip things out of extraction into regeneration, out of competition into collaboration. Women who can really diffusely listen to all the patterns and all the ways that there are marginalized populations with unmet needs. It's that kind of attunement and listening that I think is what the world sorely needs. So, if a woman is so entrenched in the mindset of like I just need to be in service of others, then that can be your why for why it's time to step into your witchiness because we need you stepping forward with this knowing and with this conviction.
How do you distinguish intuition and those feelings from, I don't know, anxiety or something else you're feeling physically? how do you distinguish the difference?
Yeah, that's my whole first book is anxiety.
Yes, I know. I remember.
And so, I think that we it to me, it's a frequency in the body and that might sound a little intangible, but let me try to make sense of it. I think that the first section of the book is about embodiment where we really want to get out of our heads. We're all navigating our lives from our heads. We want to get below the head, under the neck where we're starting to sense and feel what is my not just my head saying right now, but what's my heart saying? What's my gut saying? What's the womb saying? And if you don't have a womb, there's still an energetic womb. And there's ways that I think our intuition is not really landing through the hemispheres of the brain. I think it's coming in through these other antennae.
And so, it it's a practice of learning here's how my body says yes. Here's how my body says no. Yes can be more of an expansive, warm, open, easeful feeling. No can be a contraction, a tightness, a coldness, an uneasy feeling. you might start to sweat when your body is saying no. I remember one time I was having a job interview and there was like a real hard sell of like take this job, and in my mind cerebrally it was the dream job and I found myself kind of saying yes, but I was sitting there in the interview, my body was in knots.
Mhm.
And I ended up trusting my body and saying no and then a few months later it became so apparent why that would not have been the right job for me. So, it's these body signals and intuition interestingly it's different from fear and anxiety in the way that it's kind of neutral. It's a period at the end of the sentence and we can have an intuitive knowing about something positive and that is easy to recognize but we can even have an intuitive knowing about something that's going to be challenging but there's still a feeling of neutrality and easiness not a grasping quality. That's more likely to be fear.
It's interesting because I do think about that. I'm like, oh, maybe I'm just nervous about it or I don't want to do it and so my body is reacting that way which can really be intuition.
It can be. I mean, I think that we're charged up and I think ultimately what we want is to have some practices for clearing out some of the noise, some of the rushing around in the distraction so we can listen. This is my new framing around meditation because I used to be like, I'm trying to meditate. I'm trying to clear my mind and that didn't succeed but I think that now I think of it as my listening time. I did that this morning. It's almost like we have a shared to-do list with source and it's trying to give us instructions but we're too busy. We're not even hearing it and so if we can show up and listen in stillness for a couple minutes. Doesn't have to be fancy. We don't need special training or gear or anything.
It's just I'm listening. I'm available and then you hear what comes through and importantly you also trust what comes through.
Has that made you know, you're a New Yorker. You walk out on the street here and everything's coming at you a million miles an hour. I can imagine with, you know, the way the world is, people are raising kids, trying to get to work, taking care of parents, dealing with menopause, dealing with health issues. It's hard to find that moment to be calm. Does that help ground you even if it's for a few minutes or a few seconds?
I say the smallest bite-size piece of meditation is amazing. I'm so much more interested in the delta between doing nothing and doing anything at all. Anything that's not nothing versus the 20-minute twice a day ideal meditation. I did it for about a minute and a half this morning.
And you're so calm. I feel you, Ellen. I want to help women really return to their power with your words and your advice. I do want to go back to the book for a minute though because you organize it around embodiment, which you just mentioned, presence, valuing the yin, opening to mystery, and serving the collective. So, what are those five practices helping us recover?
Yeah, so the book opens with the aha moment, but then there's the nitty-gritty daily life of how do we gather this power? How do we make sure that we're using it for good and not for ill? And that presence section, I think of that as a very important part of the book. And I focus on integrity and sovereignty. The analogy I like is that there's this When we're talking about integrity, I think it goes into some pretty dicey subject matter. It talks about our relationships with our mothers-in-law and all of this legacy of how we really girl-on-girl crime and how we say she's crazy and she's irrational and I can't stand her and how we can sometimes be manipulative. And I give a lot of grace to that.
We're not bad people. It's that we have historically been denied a platform for getting our needs met. So, this is how we use indirect means just to try to survive. But it can sometimes take us out of alignment. It can mean that we're serving ourselves, that we might not even be aware of our motives at all times. We really want to do that shadow work and know here are my motives. I want to be in service. I'm speaking in a way that's straightforward around that. Sovereignty has to do with the fact that we also don't want to be vulnerable to being influenced by forces around us that don't necessarily have ours or anybody's best interests in mind. So, we need to be fully home. I think about it like a house with the lights on.
No one's invading that. We are at home. You can see our We're sort of beaming from behind our eyes. And our world really takes us out of our home a lot of the time.
Yes, it does.
We're distracted, we're dissociated, we're addicted, and I think that that makes it so much easier for something else to drive the ship. And if we're going to be powerful, we need to make sure we're in integrity, but we're also in sovereignty, so that we're the ones driving the ship, and we're doing it in service of good.
And people will see that from the outside. If your lights are on. Yes. And you're valuing Yin.
Yeah. So, this is the ancient Taoist symbol of the Yin Yang, and we all recognize we are living in a moment of an obsession with Yang. Productivity, action, doing, and that's great, but the ancient Taoist philosophers, I think they got this one right, which is that this is a 50/50 dynamic equilibrium, and we're living out of balanced. It's like a bloated Yang and a squished with liver Yin, and I think women in particular pay the price of the missing Yin. We're in a Yin is like an endangered species in modern life, but I think that has a lot to do with our period problems. It has a lot to do with our exhaustion, our burnout, even our resentment, fertility issues. All of this can, I believe, trace back to the fact that we do not have the space for Yin, for rest, for that Yin kind of deep nourishment, for the non-doing, surrendered, receptive state, and interestingly, I think the Yin phases of the moon, of the menstrual cycle, of the life cycle, that's where the magic happens, and so not only are we unhealthy and out of balance when we don't value Yin, but we're also missing out on a lot of intuitive downloads.
When you talk about, or anybody talks about the witch archetype, it's kind of this older woman that people aren't paying attention to anymore, maybe considered a threat to society. Why is that? the definition we have of it if this I mean, I can just picture it in my mind with the black hat. And when you So, when you call the book Season of the Witch, I was like, "Oh, what is that? Who's a witch? Are we all witches?"
We're all witches, but postmenopausal women especially so. And I think that for all the right reasons. Yes, and it almost seems like it's no accident that we've been culturally trained to devalue those women, that they are invisible, that they are gnarled, that they're unattractive. We don't culturally celebrate their value. It's almost like because they're the ones that have the wisdom that could write this ship, but we're really being trained to not hear that wisdom. And so I think there's a chapter in the book about menopause, season of the crone, and I think that especially to the postmenopausal woman, I want her to at least like I think it's hard to train the culture to value her, but I want her to really see the immense value cuz I think she in particular is the one that holds the keys.
That's the wisdom that is the salve to what ails us as a collective. And these are the women that need to step forward and say, well, here's I was up at 3:00 in the morning and here's what I know.
I I'm so glad you said that because I think when we use a you know, we say postmenopausal, people are like it's all over, but really this is the beginning of another 30 to 40 years of a lifespan that we've never had before. Right? What should those women know because there are the days that they're up at 3:00 in the morning, they feel awful, they've gained weight that they don't know where it came from, they can't fall asleep because their husbands just breathing.
Existing.
You know, existing. They are trying to work out, they're trying to do all of it. How do they begin to feel that about themselves? What do they need to feel in themselves to start building back that trust to even be able to listen?
Yeah. Well, I like understanding it from an ancestral perspective and what's so interesting about menopause is I'm a functional medicine physician. The way I approach if someone has heartburn, I'm thinking about well, this system, this design of the human body is actually a pretty good design. It works. So if you're having heartburn, it tells us there's some kind of physical imbalance. Let's identify the root cause of it and let's address it. And that's great for just about every medical ailment except menopause. is a quirk. It's a medical anomaly in that most of how we've refined the body is through natural selection, and natural selection hinges on reproduction. So, if you get a mutation and it makes you more successful at reproduction and having successful offspring, then that mutation gets selected for over millennia of evolution.
And menopause is by definition post-reproductive. So, even if one lucky postmenopausal woman has a de novo mutation that makes her better adapted to the symptoms of menopause, lucky her, but it dies with her cuz it doesn't actually help her survive and have more successful offspring. The grandmother effect still valid. It's a relatively weak effect, but basically, women surviving and having being available to help care for grandchildren and to offer wisdom, we see this in some of the most interesting species. It's still an effect, but ultimately, the ways we're symptomatic, the ways we suffer in the postmenopausal years, the theory that I think is most compelling is that the body really only has the software left over from the previous, the precedent for a big estrogen drop, which is the postpartum period.
So, then it's like we are mobilizing calcium because it's helpful for making breast milk, but a bummer for bone density. We are emanating heat because we want to warm an infant, which is useful in the postpartum period and quite uncomfortable in the middle of a board meeting. Yes. And and even fragile sleep, superficial sleep is adaptive if you have a newborn and you need to wake up to their cry, but then it's miserable in midlife. And I think the metaphor that emerges from this is that we are in a different postpartum period. We are reborn. It's not that we're now giving our life blood and our life force energy to our offspring. It's that we're giving it to a new version of ourselves that's being born.
And what is so fascinating is that it would seem that the sex hormones like estrogen and progesterone, these are creating an almost biological imperative for us to play well in the sandbox, to people please, to be docile, to tilt our head, to put everybody at ease.
Yeah.
And it's almost like we can't help ourselves in the reproductive years cuz it's hardwired and it does make us more reproductively successful. But as those hormones wane, we're liberated from that. And now we don't have to make nice in quite the same which does not mean we're just ruthless and needlessly cruel. It means we're going to say the real truth even if it's going to ruffle some feathers. And man are we in a moment in history when we need women stepping forward and doing exactly that.
There's no question at all. I love how you explain all of that, the hot flashes, the lack of sleep, all of the different things that we have going on from the post reproductive years, the post partum years to where we are with men.
I paused and I never thought So when women in midlife come into your practice now to see you, what are you hearing most from them these days?
Many things. I think that part of what I'm hearing is just the symptoms are struggle and while we're now running back the conclusions we drew about the women's health initiative in the past and so there's access to hormone replacement therapy, it's still not always a straightforward journey and there's troubleshooting and there's frustrations in that and there's still doctors closing doors in our faces. We're still getting gaslit or bullied or not feeling heard and Oh, it's dark out there.
It is dark out there, I know.
Every once in a while I feel like I take years away from allopathic medicine and I think surely by now they're understanding root cause resolution and to validate someone's subjective experience and then I re-enter that world and I'm like, nope,
Still here.
Still the Stone Ages, yeah, the Dark Ages. So that's part of what I'm hearing. that feeling of the world is considering me invisible and I don't want to be invisible. I'm not ready to be invisible. In fact, I feel like I have more to offer now. And so I'm really interested in latching onto that one and leaning into that that Let's stay with that more to offer because we don't need to take our cues from how the world is responding to us. We can step into that worthiness regardless of how what's being mirrored back to us.
I feel like we're starting to do that, but I feel like it's going to be the same climb, maybe even more, of what we saw with menopause and midlife and women's health cuz when I go back and look 6 years ago when I started the conversation, to where we are, and to your point, we have women that are still being dismissed and pushed away, or made to feel like they're crazy.
Yeah.
It's shocking how much it's ingrained in our culture and how we're treated in the medical system and on
And I And maybe two other quick thoughts on that. But I think that also the fact that there are sleepless nights, and then we feel brain fog, and we don't feel as cognitively as sharp, and that's a very painful feeling, especially in this world that's constantly evaluating us on that cognitive sharpness, on that left hemispheric clarity. And I, you know, we all don't like tossing and turning in the middle of the night, but it is sometimes inevitable. And can we make peace with that and see those middle of the night hours as actually a very special liminal time. I think the veil is thinner at that time. There are insights that come through. And in the next morning, when we feel a little foggier, we might be foggier in the sense of what the world is asking of us, that kind of cognitive sharpness and word-finding ability, but we have a different type of clarity and insight that's also valuable.
I like thinking about that cuz it's those quiet times where you're alone and there's no noise coming in, and you're in a different state. That's interesting.
Yeah. I'll start to learn to appreciate it a little bit more, Alana.
Slightly. Just slightly.
I think with a lot of women, when we return to our power during this time, like you said, saying what's on our mind, feeling a little more selfish, taking care of ourselves a little bit more, listening to our intuition, it can feel selfish and almost a little bit dangerous, too. Do you agree? And if that's How do I mean?
How do you mean dangerous?
Oh, I mean it's a little scary to step out there and do something you haven't been doing for the last 50 years. You know what I mean? It's scary to listen to your intuition. It's scary to step forward and say whatever on your mind. What do you do to help the woman that's going, "I don't know if that's where I am right now. I'd like to be where Ellen is, but I don't know. if I'm a witch."
I think we are all witches. I think you in particular definitely witch. You Remind me you said a couple words there like dangerous, but you also said selfish?
Selfish. Thank you. Okay. So, I think that word is due for reconsideration.
Yes.
And so, because all of this biological imperative to make nice and exist in selfless service of everyone around us, we know how that story ends, and it's not always such a great ending to that. I think the fact that selfish is the ultimate scarlet letter to brand on a woman is part of why we are losing our goddamn minds. And I think that No, man. I don't know any man I call that's been called selfish.
Right. We take men down in completely different ways, but the fact that we're not allowed to be a meat suit with needs that sometimes has to receive and ask for things in order to meet those needs puts us in the position of burnout and resentment and needing to manipulate. And I think it often creates all sorts of weird codependency and performances of selflessness that we'd all actually just be a little better off if we had permission to say, "I actually have a need right now, and I'm going to ask for that need to be met." Nonviolent Communication by Marshall B. Rosenberg has a beautiful formula for this, which is that expressing a need is not the same as obligating somebody into meeting that need.
In fact, that whole system of obligation culture has a lot more to do with we all have to perform selflessness, but then indirectly obligate each other to meeting our needs cuz how else are we getting our needs met? If we can just speak openly and say, "Here's a need. I'm giving you an opportunity to enrich my life. Take it or leave it." Then someone can say, "Sorry, I can't help you move this weekend." And it's like, "Okay, no harm, no foul." Versus we do all kinds of indirect things instead and it breeds resentment in every direction. Think we're a little better off stepping out and saying, "I am a little selfish cuz I have a meat suit that has all kinds of needs."
The meat suit makes me cringe.
Yeah, it's not a pretty term.
So, what role does anger and desire play in leading us back to ourselves?
Mhm. When I hear you say those words, my initial reaction is that those are very sacred feelings. And of course, we don't want to be dysregulated. We don't want to be stuck in a mentality of resentment and that there's not an all-one-size-fits-all approach to understanding anger. But a lot of anger is a very soul level divine, like this is not okay. And I think we probably would all stand to benefit from more of us giving ourselves permission to be with that and to let it move, to not let it get lodged in us and stay stuck.
Why do you think this is the season of the witch?
So, I was saying earlier that there's this confluence. It's both that we're resourced, that we have pioneers opening up a conversation around menopause, that the younger generations are more open in these public forums. But then I don't think we can afford to wait. It feels like there's an urgency. There's a relative safety. Like it was not safe to be a witchy woman historically and we can't overlook that or there's no we can't emphasize that enough. But we're not perfectly safe, but we are relatively safe and I feel an urgency in terms of what's at stake on a planetary level. And I think we're even entering like I'm looking at the Lindsey Clancy trial right now.
Sure.
And I think we're having a reckoning of relationships between men and women, the needs of a postpartum woman, we're having the postpartum me, too, right now, where we're coming forth and saying, you know, this was hidden behind secrecy and shame, but hey, me, too. I also struggled in the postpartum period. I also had darker, scary thoughts in that period. I also had thoughts I didn't feel comfortable naming. And I think then, once we have that out in the open and we're talking about it, we can show up and meet these needs in the way that we've been overdue for so long. And so, I think it's also the season of the witch because we have this opportunity to bring everything out in the open to say, okay, this guy is rational and linear and great at parallel parking and he thinks that's the only way.
And we love that, we value that, yet we have this woman over here feeling less than because those are not the qualities that come naturally to her. And she's thinking this is superior, this is inferior, just need a rebalancing. It's not taking this down, it's just saying her qualities of intuition, of collaboration and attunement and diffuse awareness and all that emotional intelligence, that is equally valuable and it's been diminished for a very long time and the world needs it desperately. So, I want that woman to step forward into a sense of her worthiness. So, how does a woman start allowing magic back into her life? So, cuz I'm thinking like where can I put magic back into my life right now?
And then I'm sure it quickly becomes the industrial complex of magic, consumerized, and it's all I have a to-do list for my magic.
Have I got a tarot deck to sell you?
But I think it'll look different for all of us. All I can really share is what I know from my own life, from my patients. but I like to demystify it and show that it's very simple and straightforward and can happen in a moment-to-moment way. But like for me, if I am struggling with a decision, I will ask my parents for help. I will ask for clarity. If I if a particular song comes on and it's something that holds special significance between me and someone I've lost, I don't just think like, oh, that's a funny coincidence. I think, hi. Maybe you're here right now. I just open to that. And so it it's when I'm writing, that's such a wrestling with demons process and so you better believe I'm asking for all the help I can get from the other side and I'm lighting a candle and saying a prayer and really trying to call in that help and also set an intention to be of service.
And then I redo that whole process anytime I have to get up and go to the bathroom or get a snack or refill my coffee cuz it slips and then you're back out of it and then sometimes I'll forget and I'm like, why is this so hard and nothing's flowing? And then I realize I didn't reset the intention and then I do it. And I think there's some way that I've come to appreciate that this spirit world is not going to just intervene. We have free will, it's not going to get in our business unless we ask. So I ask. all the time.
What has magic restored in you?
Mhm. It certainly charms this existence. It I'm someone who has a lot of fear like we all do. And it's not that I have eradicated fear. I still take this material existence very seriously and want to be careful when I'm crossing the street. But the fact that I feel my parents makes me play around with the idea of what is there really to fear? Cuz they continue to exist. I sense it. I feel it. almost feels like this undeniable knowing. So I think it's all up for grabs what's really happening here. And that certainly softens a lot of the biggest existential fears that we're all carrying just under the surface whether we're consciously aware of it or not.
I want to ask you something, Alan. Were you nervous about a book that had psychiatrist and witch on it?
I probably should be.
No, I was just wondering. I was just thinking to myself like that's a very bold brave book to write.
Brave is the scariest word that people used to describe me because I don't I'm not brave. I don't want to be brave.
I'm just taking the call from spirit of what I'm supposed to write about and I asked over and over again. I would pray. I would say, "Are you sure? Is this what I should be writing?"
Really?
And I needed that reinforcement and that clarity cuz I mean one doubts what they're writing about a million times a day for all kinds of different reasons.
I'm doing it right now so I understand exactly what you're talking about.
So we wrestle with it and I found that it was really helpful to just keep asking. I was like, "Show me. Make it clear for me. Is this the right track or am I off track or should I go somewhere else?"
So somebody's doing something in that you know they're thinking of something say something then they see the word somewhere later on and they see they hear somebody say something. Is that all intuition? Is that all what you're talking about?
So it can be and there's all sorts of cognitive biases and so sometimes it's not. Sometimes coincidences do happen but I find that there's an extra little salience, an extra little tingling feeling that I have when it is something more in my choice of how to receive this. And when there's that feeling of salience I pause and maybe it's just a moment of okay, that's a connection with something that makes life feel a little bit like it buoys your spirit a bit and sometimes it's slow down and pay attention. There's something to notice here. Maybe it's some way that we've gotten off course. And so if you're noticing synchronicities or signs or something that connects you to somebody that you've lost I really just want to encourage people don't miss that magic. not to say go all the way off the deep end with magical thinking like we need to meet somewhere in the middle but most of us have been airing on the side of missing out on an openness to that.
And so when it comes through, when you feel that salience, you can listen to it. Maybe it comforts you, maybe it guides you.
And then the final one, because I am fascinated by this. So, you're practicing as a holistic and functional psychiatrist and then writing this book on the season of the witch and magic. How did writing this book change how you practice if it did at all with your patients day-to-day?
Well, I think the journey to opening to magic is what most profoundly changed my practice, but in the past, I was just a psychiatrist, just in the room, dialogue, clipboard, pen, paper. And now I feel like I'm in the room with a team of helpers around me. I say a prayer before any patient encounter And I ask for source and ancestors and team of light to work through me in service of the patient's highest and greatest. But I also ask again if I'm stuck, if I'm at an impasse, if I feel like I really want to help someone here and I don't know how to do it. It's beyond the limitations of my intellect and my training and I need like I need a miracle sometimes for the patient. And so I ask and it's been chilling. It's been awe-inspiring how something shifts when I double down on that and ask again and that's usually when something comes through. That's usually the moment where I happen to say the word or bring up the memory or something that's come up in our therapy that makes a patient catch and then sometimes that's when they start to cry and that's sometimes when the softening and the shift occurs.
And I'll this will never get old for me, the fact that when I ask for help from something beyond my abilities, that's when what the patient needs comes through.
How do you ask that question?
Like silently trying to not move my lips.
But how like what are the words? Because I think that that sometimes that's hard. Some people go like I don't know how to do that.
Yeah. I don't know. I've never been comfortable with that. It's woo-woo to me. That's not who I am.
It almost feels embarrassing to talk about this out loud, but Okay, so I'm going to make you do that.
So it takes a lot of different forms, but sometimes it's like I'm interfacing with a patient and then something is stuck here and I basically say, "Please help." But it's sometimes just as simple as that, like "Please help." And I sort of in my mind's eye look up and I'll sometimes add words like in gratitude, in reverence, in humility, I'm asking for help. And so that's usually how I set that intention. And but sometimes it's very quick cuz there isn't time for all the humility and reverence and then it's just like "Please help."
You only have 45 minutes, right?
I am so excited for people to read this book. I really am. Congratulations.
Thank you. Can I bring us to one final anecdote Yes.
If we have the time for it? As much time as you want, Ellen.
So if you remember from the acupuncture treatment with Momoko, she told me it's time to stop reading books and start writing books. In retrospect, it was a weird thing for my mom to say to me because I'm like pretty dyslexic and can barely read. And so it's like "Stop reading books, okay. The one book I'm reading this year." But also she was a librarian. She was the consummate reader. My mom read practically a book a day. And in the time since that acupuncture treatment, now both of my parents have passed away. My sister and I are doing the laborious and impossibly nostalgic task of clearing out our childhood home. And one weekend my sister was there alone and she found on my mom's desk under piles of library books and stationery, she found a half-finished novel by my mom.
Wow.
And when she told me about that, all that experience with Momoko came crashing back and I realized when my mom was saying it's time to stop reading books and start writing books, that took on more layers.
Sure does.
She wasn't just saying that to me. She was saying it to herself. She was saying it in a way that I think especially in a matriarchal lineage, we are carrying out the unrealized dreams of our ancestors and so here I am. I've written two books and I really hope that my librarian mom is right here with me getting to enjoy the fulfillment of that.
I hope you can feel her here.
I do.
Ellen, thank you.
medical disclaimer:
The information provided in this podcast is for educational and informational purposes only and is not intended as medical advice. Always consult with a qualified healthcare professional regarding any medical concerns or treatment options. The views expressed by guests are their own and do not necessarily reflect those of The Tamsen Show.






