Episode Description
Most women can't remember the last time they didn't feel guilty about something. Not calling a parent back, saying no to a kid, taking a weekend for themselves, or lying awake going over everything they got wrong that day. Psychiatrist Dr. Jennifer Reid hears it from her patients constantly, and she felt it herself, which is why she wrote Guilt Free: Reclaiming Your Life from Unreasonable Expectations.
Her argument is that most of the guilt women carry isn't a sign they've done anything wrong. It comes from the gap between the expectations we were taught to hold and the small part of our lives we let ourselves notice. In this episode, Jennifer reveals where those expectations come from, why they get heavier in midlife, and what changes when you start counting yourself among the people you take care of.
If you've ever felt like you're falling behind without knowing what you did wrong, this one is for you.
In this episode, you'll learn:
- Why constant guilt usually isn't about doing wrong, and what it's actually measuring
- The "Four Furies" women are taught to carry: constant caretaking, hyper-accountability, chasing perfection, and having it all without asking for help
- How guilt can stand in for anger women don't feel safe expressing
- Why guilt and care aren't the same thing, and how to love someone and still say no
- Learning to disappoint people, and why it's not as dangerous as it feels
- Why self-compassion motivates you better than self-criticism
- Jennifer's SPEAK framework for moving from guilt toward agency
- Why midlife can be the moment to turn back inward and ask what you actually want
Timestamps
0:00 Intro
0:59 Why guilt became the focus of the book
3:11 The Four Furies
4:40 The Guilt Equation
6:12 The three blessings exercise
11:12 Constant caretaking
13:41 Hyper-accountability: do men feel this way?
16:19 Seeking perfection
17:20 Having it all
18:31 Guilt in midlife and menopause
20:46 Why guilt is so hard to let go
26:46 Learning to disappoint people
31:06 The SPEAK framework
34:32 What to put in guilt's place
Share with a Friend
If you liked this episode, listen to these episodes
guest appearing in this episode
Dr. Jennifer Reid
Dr. Jennifer Reid is a psychiatrist and the author of Guilt Free: Reclaiming Your Life from Unreasonable Expectations. In her work, she helps women identify the unreasonable expectations driving constant guilt, perfectionism, and people-pleasing and replace them with a more grounded, compassionate way of seeing themselves and their lives. She is the creator of the SPEAK Framework, a practical practice for noticing guilty thoughts, examining the expectations behind them, and taking action toward agency.

Dr. Reid's new book
Guilt Free: Reclaiming Your Life from Unreasonable Expectations
by Jennifer Reid, MD
A practical guide from psychiatrist Dr. Jennifer Reid on loosening the grip of unreasonable guilt, people-pleasing, and the expectations women are taught to carry. Out January 27, 2026 from Penguin Life.
Get the book
Visit the official book page: Guilt Free
Visit Dr. Reid's website
Follow Dr. Reid on Instagram
A Mind of Her Own on Substack
Other related resources
Guilt Free: Reclaiming Your Life from Unreasonable Expectations by Dr. Jennifer Reid

get this episode’s free download
Four Furies Guilt Decoder
Did my conversation with Dr. Jennifer Reid on The Tamsen Show leave you thinking about everything you expect of yourself? This free workbook helps you unpack that guilt and question the expectations behind it.
Read full transcript
Tamsen Fadal: Jennifer, thanks so much for being here.
Dr. Jennifer Reid: Thank you for having me. I'm excited.
Tamsen Fadal: Well, I am too because I have so many questions for you as I think so many other people will. You know, you've you've written this incredible book called Guilt Free: Reclaiming Your Life from Unreasonable Expectations, which I think so many women are going to relate to that just that title alone. But I'm curious about something. You open the book with a patient who says the only time that they don't feel guilty is when they're sleeping. And I went, oh my gosh, I so feel that in so many different ways. Yeah. How did guilt become such a topic for you to cover?
Dr. Jennifer Reid: Well, it was patients like that that were telling me, I don't know what I've done wrong. I don't know what I'm failing at, but I just have this persistent sense that I'm falling behind, I'm disorganized, I'm not winning. And I really felt the same way myself. And I was talking to my older sister who's this amazing breast surgeon and raising good family. And we were both describing that feeling. So it was it was kind of everywhere. And I thought there's got to be some way to start making a change here.
Tamsen Fadal: Were you seeing as a psychiatrist that sitting underneath everything, sitting under anxiety and exhaustion and unhappiness with patients that were coming into your room every day?
Dr. Jennifer Reid: It was almost like guilt stepped in to protect them from those other emotions. It stepped in for anger. Maybe it wasn't they didn't feel like comfortable expressing anger or they didn't safe expressing anger. So guilt came in to say, oh, I shouldn't be so angry. That's wrong. That's not fair. I need to just change something within myself. So I saw it as covering up all of these other important emotions.
Tamsen Fadal: You know, I use the word guilty all the time because I think about it. I'm I feel guilty I haven't done this. I haven't been guilty. I didn't call my dad today. I feel guilty I didn't tell my husband you know pay attention to what my husband was talking about or or contribute enough time to something. I guess we tend to treat it as evidence we've done something wrong. But if we haven't really done something wrong, what is it telling us?
Dr. Jennifer Reid: Right. So at its most adaptive, guilt is directly focused on something we maybe did do wrong, right? Maybe I forgot to call my sister on her birthday and I thought, oh, I feel awful. But what I'm hearing from so many women in particular is constant guilt, this sense that everything I do is one step lower than it should be. Like you said, it's not enough. A lot of those kinds of words. And so that's where we really get into this sense of guilt all the time pervasive that I'm not living up to expectations that I have for myself. But what I wanted to get into in the book is where did those expectations come from? It's not just us creating this within ourselves. What is it? So the expectations, the four key ones, I call them the Four Furies because they are really they cause so much suffering.
Constant caretaking. We need to take care of everyone often at our own expense. Hyper-accountability. We're responsible for other people's emotional experience. If I don't call my mom and she feels sad, then I'm a bad daughter, right? If my child feels disappointed, I'm a bad mother. There's this seeking perfection, this idea that women we need to be above reproach in so many different ways, appearance, body image, sexual interest, productivity at work. And the final one is really having it all. That somehow we can do that without any signs of effort and without any help. And I think these four types of expectations we're taught to carry.
Tamsen Fadal: Is it women that are taught to carry or is it everybody that's taught to carry?
Dr. Jennifer Reid: I think women are particularly taught to carry these, especially when you think about constant caretaking. There's this sense that it's this maternal like natural instinct. And yes, we do care for our children and love them deeply, but this idea that we need to do it perfectly and for everyone, otherwise we're failing as women, that's where we start to get into the guilt.
Tamsen Fadal: Yeah, I think we have to dive into each one of those Four Furies because they're they're so important. I guess the the question I had before we do that, how do you distinguish guilt that should lead to accountability and repair, right, from guilt that is created by an expectation we could never we could never even handle, you know, we could never get to?
Dr. Jennifer Reid: Well, I wanted to come up with something to simplify this really complex, constant, all day long feeling. And I came up with the Guilt Equation just because I was like math seems to be very clear, right? Let's do this. So our guilt is our expectations for ourselves minus our perceived reality, minus what we are noticing that we're already doing well in our lives.
Tamsen Fadal: Okay, we have to go back to that again. Break it down for me.
Dr. Jennifer Reid: Okay. So it's our expectations of ourselves. So let's say as far as being a mother, for example, my expectation is that a mother would never disappoint her kids. Let's start there. Then we look at the perceived reality part. I noticed that today I just did everything wrong. I was a bad mom. Well, maybe what that actually meant is I said no to something and I noticed they were disappointed. I may have made them breakfast. I may have made sure they had gotten off to school with everything they needed, said I loved them, gave them a kiss goodbye, all these things I've done. I don't notice any of that. I just notice what I haven't done. And that's where that guilt lives in that gap between what I think I should be able to do in all these roles and what I'm actually seeing myself do.
Tamsen Fadal: So how do we get to a place where we actually see all those other things? Cuz you're right. I I would imagine somebody goes, those are the things I'm supposed to do. I can't I don't count those as any big achievement. That's what I'm supposed to do, but look at this other thing I was really supposed to do and I failed there.
Dr. Jennifer Reid: Absolutely. And that's the challenge is how do we focus our attention on the things we're doing well because where we pay attention, that truly is our life. That's what we experience. So, what I wanted to talk through are different strategies to really savor those things that we're doing well, shift our attention. There's this exercise in positive psychology, which is this whole wonderful field of psychology focused on helping people move from, you know, just regular day to really flourishing. And it's called the three blessings exercise. So at the end of the day, you take out a note paper or you can do this at the dinner table, which I do, and you write down three things that went well that day and why. And it's really simple, but it's very different from what you you may do, I certainly do, which is lie in bed and think, what did I not get done today, right?
What did I mess up today? What did I say wrong to somebody? And so that's one simple way, but there are a number of ways to try and shift our attention.
Tamsen Fadal: Is there a reason that women are so quick to notice that perceived reality, what we haven't done perfectly or well versus the things that we have well.
Dr. Jennifer Reid: Well, I think carrying these heavy expectations that we need to check all of these boxes to be valuable, to be loved, even to be liked, right? The idea of likeability is really important and I think embedded in us way back when that we needed to be part of a community that helped us raise children, helped us all survive, protected each other, that's carried forth and so feeling disliked is a very difficult visceral feeling, right? It just feels awful. So I think that that's adding this additional pressure that not only do we need to do everything perfectly, but in a way that somehow everybody will like and approve of. And maybe that's adaptive in some small ways, but boy, it keeps us just bending over backwards and exhausted.
Tamsen Fadal: Yeah, I mean I just think that I lay in bed at night and I make a list of the things that I didn't do well, right? Or somebody I might have upset and and they're not even realistic things. You know, and then I try to say like tomorrow it's going to be perfect and I understand what I'm doing, but I can't, you know, break that cycle. So so let's talk about that. When women are especially vulnerable to excessive guilt, what do you say to somebody that walks in and and and is saying like I I'm sorry, I just can't break this? Where do you begin doing that? Is that with the three blessings?
Dr. Jennifer Reid: What I would begin with is just describing what is guilt? What are you feeling? Because so many women have actually said to me I don't think I have a lot of guilt. And then we've started talking about what it is and they're like oh, I have it all day long. So part of it is just helping them see when you have this guilty thought, let's plug it, let's look at those expectations. Where are they coming from? Maybe there's a certain role that you carry a lot more guilt as a daughter of, you know, aging parents, as a mother. What is a particular guilty thought in that moment? And let's examine it this way. Let's plug in the equation, let's look at what your expectations are. Are those the ones you want to keep? And let's look at this perceived reality. What are you noticing and what could you be overlooking? So we get very specific. The equation is for everyone, but we use it to specifically examine someone's particular thought.
Tamsen Fadal: How do people walk away uh after a certain amount of time of practicing that? I I have to imagine with a lot more freedom and feeling uh very a lot less on their shoulders.
Dr. Jennifer Reid: Right. It removes this heavy layer that everything out there is my fault, that I'm responsible for everything. And when your sort of circle of responsibility expands so far beyond your circle of control, you constantly feel like you're failing. But you can't control so much of what's happening around you. Even as hard as you try, you can't control the health and happiness of your children or your friends or family. You can only do your best to move in that direction, but also trying to be compassionate towards yourself that you can't control all of that.
Tamsen Fadal: So I want to go back to the Four Furies because I I think that that you know those hit everybody, right? The constant caretaking, the hyper-accountability, the seeking perfection. They pain me as I read them. And then trying to have it all. Can we go through each one of those and break them down starting with the the constant caretaking?
Dr. Jennifer Reid: So constant caretaking, think about that as being the perfect mother or the perfect daughter, right? Let's say the perfect daughter would never say anything to her parents that made them feel disappointed or that she wasn't 100% grateful. For example, if she had this really amazing job opportunity in another city and she wanted to move away from her parents, but she knew that would be disappointing to them. She might the guilt might actually make that decision for her. She'll say, oh, I can't do that. It would just be too hard for them. I'm going to just stay here and let that go.
Tamsen Fadal: And then be resentful.
Dr. Jennifer Reid: And then exactly. There's a cost to be resentful and then maybe even start to pull away from those relationships because you're so frustrated that you weren't able to really grow in the direction you want to grow because guilt was telling you, no, you shouldn't.
Tamsen Fadal: What do you do? How do you tackle that one? That's a big one.
Dr. Jennifer Reid: It's a big one. I think looking at we have this idea called reflected appraisals in interpersonal therapy, this idea that we see ourselves the way that it was reflected back to us growing up. So, you know, the labels we might get, you're the black sheep, or you're the smart one, or you're the one who takes care of everybody, you know, that we can carry these labels forward. So, really, we have to look at: what were we taught about what it means to be a good daughter, mother, friend? Who were our role models? And really look at: are those role models adhering to the values that are really important to us, or are we just carrying this sort of old blueprint forward that doesn't actually work for us?
Tamsen Fadal: If you're carrying the old blueprint forward, how do you start to undo that? Because that is years of expectations, societal expectation, family expectation, and then all you ever know.
Dr. Jennifer Reid: Well, I think first just recognizing that this was something that you were taught and trained to do. I think there's some power in that because it's not, oh, I'm just getting this wrong, I have it all mixed up. It's saying, look, someone else is putting this label on me. I have the opportunity to move back away from that. And it's turning that attention inward. And for so many women, the woman at the beginning of the book, it feels selfish to pay attention to herself, even if she's just examining her own thoughts or her own feelings. But this is the only way we can start to understand and then start to rewrite them. We do some work in cognitive behavioral therapy of sort of rewriting these distorted thoughts that say I'm only a good daughter if, right? And bringing even more neutral or maybe more positive thoughts. So those are some of the strategies we might use.
Tamsen Fadal: Hyper-accountability, what is that? Explain that. This one I definitely experience this one all the time.
Dr. Jennifer Reid: This idea that somehow again our responsibility is so so broad that we can truly control how someone else will feel, what they will think about, what they will experience, what their lives will be like for that matter. I think there's this sense that we might replay over and over, what did I say and could I have said it differently to make sure they didn't feel whatever it might be, right? So when we're trying to share our own needs, it might feel like, oh, that's selfish because it might make someone else feel badly.
Tamsen Fadal: I I just have to ask you, do men feel like this? Cuz I don't I don't imagine if I said to even my husband, like, do you feel And I have asked him before, do you feel guilty about this? He's like, no. It's a It's actually the furthest thing from his mind. He couldn't even fathom what I'm talking about.
Dr. Jennifer Reid: It's really true that women, I think, we we talk about it amongst ourselves a lot more often. I think that there are emotions that each sort of When we look at these gender roles that men and women are kind of allowed to feel and express. And then for men, I talked to my husband about this too and I said, how much guilt? He said, I don't have a lot of guilt. I think mine turns to anger. Okay. So instead of saying I've done This something bad has happened, it's my fault, I need to fix it. I did I'm bad. They would say something bad has happened. I cannot believe they did this or that happened out there. Like externalizes it more. Again, I'm generalizing. But that's really what I'm hearing is they might lean more toward feeling anger. Mhm. Whereas we're turning it inward because then of course that also doesn't hurt anyone else. We just hurt ourselves. Of course. Yeah.
Tamsen Fadal: Okay, seeking perfection. We got two more.
Dr. Jennifer Reid: Seeking perfection. I mean, we're inundated, right? With with creams, with procedures, with ideas about how can we prevent the the appearance of aging as though aging isn't a success story, that we've made it to each of these years, right? That our bodies need to be a certain way. And I see this in mental health treatment, this idea that I should be able to just relax when I feel anxious. I should be able to just make myself feel better when I'm feeling sad, right? This idea that we always need to be striving toward perfection. Okay, maybe you want to strive to grow and improve things in your life, but when you only see perfection as what makes you valuable, Mhm. there's a huge gap there. And I've never seen anyone in my practice, thousands of patients, who's ever had it all together or did anything perfectly.
I mean, that's the lens I get to see, but that's what I'm trying to communicate is is we're chasing this goal post that keeps moving further and further away.
Tamsen Fadal: I think we all need that lens that you have though, because you have the the benefit of being able to see that because, you know, you you scroll on Instagram or TikTok for 5 minutes and you think everybody's got everything together.
Dr. Jennifer Reid: Yes.
Tamsen Fadal: Trying to have it all. Can you explain that one?
Dr. Jennifer Reid: Well, I think because we've had these remarkable women before us that have opened up doors for so many of us in in career opportunities, what we want our families, our lives to look like, we have these additional opportunities. I feel like the expectations of more traditional woman's roles of caretaking, of housekeeping, of raising the children, those haven't really shifted that well, right? The expectation is still that women will also take on all of that, that second shift idea if you've read some of her work. So that's really the issue that what we're dealing with is that there's this constant feeling that I need to be on top of all of these different things and I need to do it without any sign that I'm strained or tired or, heaven forbid, asking someone, could you help me? Like could you step in and help? And maybe there's something adaptive about that and that we've really had to show we could handle anything to open these doors.
But I think we get into a position we think we can do this in isolation and this very individualistic country that we live in, and that is really creating a lot of guilt.
Tamsen Fadal: When women start to bring this into midlife and it's am I navigating my health perfectly? Am I navigating menopause perfectly so I look strong? Am I dealing with empty nest well? Am I, you know, the words that I don't love, aging gracefully? What happens during that time? Because I feel like that is a whole other burden on top of what maybe what we've been doing in our 20s and our 30s and our 40s.
Dr. Jennifer Reid: I think it is and I think there really aren't great sort of narratives of what it looks like to move through that really well without getting so bogged down in how do I do it perfectly, right? What are the things we're excited about? What are we learning? What are we experiencing? What skills have we learned throughout our lives that we're now able to bring to the world at that age? I think so much of the focus is how can I prevent decline or how can I deal with loss? And yes, there are losses that can happen during this time, but that's true of being a woman at any age. We change all the time and we're constantly coping with loss, right? As our children age, we cope with them moving from each stage that they'll never go back to. Sure. The losses as we have family and friends that are aging and and may become ill as they get older.
So we're coping with that. But I think the idea that we can do it perfectly, really pushed by the comparisons we might find out there, I think that's what's really harming women.
Tamsen Fadal: Does that mean we need more role models? We need more We need to see more women in these roles being vocal about what it takes?
Dr. Jennifer Reid: I think being vocal about what it takes, talking about their experience, whether with menopause, certainly the work that you're doing is such important work. In addition, what are the things they're growing into, right? What is the change that they're able to move into? And I'm hoping to kind of write about this next. Like what is the psychological transition that we can go through to see the future as something that we're eager to reach and explore as opposed to everything's ending and I just have to sort of make do with my sort of lower position. Just hang on down here and be be grateful for being present.
Tamsen Fadal: Yeah, I see I see a lot of that. I I I see a lot of this kind of a shrug like well, I'm I'm lucky to be here and I I really hope that we're starting to embrace this next second half in a in a whole new way especially because there's so many years ahead of us versus what we had seen before.
Dr. Jennifer Reid: Right.
Tamsen Fadal: Do you feel like some people that guilt is very seductive to some people. It's very hard to let go of. I think so. that's a weird word I guess, but I I think that's what it Yeah. what it can be described as.
Dr. Jennifer Reid: I think seductive is a great word because I think there are these tricky benefits that guilt offers that does make it really sticky for most of us. One is that it can be motivating, right? And we really think of it as motivating even if what's happening if we're using motivation through guilt like oh, I can't believe I haven't done that already. I'm such a so and so, right?
Tamsen Fadal: I'm doing so I'm I suck, exactly. That came off my tongue very quickly.
Dr. Jennifer Reid: Yeah, that was ready. You know, I think this idea that we're starting from behind. We've already failed and now we need to move forward. And so we know self-compassion works better than self-criticism and guilt to motivate. So we can start to let go. We can challenge this idea that we need to be super hard on ourselves so that we don't just crawl under the covers and never leave.
Tamsen Fadal: But you know, I think about this. I do think sometimes we believe, I believe if I'm critical of myself then it's going to motivate me more. And I have to imagine a lot of very high functioning women think the same way. If I'm tough on myself, I'm going to keep moving forward. So how do you get out of that rut?
Dr. Jennifer Reid: Well, I think first recognizing that it had been adaptive up to a point, but what is the cost? What is the cost? And the cost is that we're feeling badly about ourselves. We're feeling like we're getting everything wrong. We're feeling like we've already disappointed ourselves. It's very different to say I can't believe I haven't done that than to say I want to do that. I'm ready to do that now. I haven't done that yet, right? Like what is that optimism? What is that hope for moving forward as opposed to I've already made a mistake and I'm I'm behind. So, that's one sticky way. Another is that we conflate it with care. That if I care about someone, I must feel guilty if they are struggling or if there's any challenge they're having or if I have to say no or if I can't participate. That if I don't feel guilty, I don't care.
For example, I may have a friend who says, I'm going away for the weekend. I'm leaving my kids at home and I feel great about it. But then I feel kind of guilty that I don't feel guilty.
Tamsen Fadal: Oh gosh. I heard that recently.
Dr. Jennifer Reid: Yeah. I feel guilty that I don't feel guilty. Yes.
Tamsen Fadal: I mean, that is just what it's just a cycle it's a circle inside of a circle inside of a circle. Mhm. And what do you do with that? What do you tell somebody that comes in and says, I feel guilty for not feeling guilty? I mean, that really is a lot to unravel.
Dr. Jennifer Reid: It is, but I think it highlights so beautifully how expected guilt is. How much we think guilt should be present in all of these scenes. She's really feeling guilty that she doesn't care. But that's where we need to talk about the fact that guilt and care can be very different things, right? We can leave our children for the weekend and say, I really care about you. I hope you have a wonderful time. I'm going to miss you. That doesn't mean we feel guilty cuz guilt says I've done something wrong.
Tamsen Fadal: And that weekend might be just the ticket. It may not be anything wrong. And it may be what exactly what you need to be moving forward with a healthy relationship.
Dr. Jennifer Reid: Absolutely.
Tamsen Fadal: You wrote something interesting that being happy makes us feel vulnerable. Why is that?
Dr. Jennifer Reid: Well, I think there's this sense that the other shoe might drop, right? That somehow if we feel too happy, we're not protecting ourselves against something bad happening or disappointment. But what I talk to a lot of people about is if you have something that happens that's really a struggle, you have a loss or a disappointment, you're going to feel those emotions. That's human. We can't protect ourselves preemptively from feeling it by just never allowing ourselves to get too happy.
Tamsen Fadal: But I think a lot of us I mean I I understand it very clearly, so I I obviously have am am fall victim to it. So what do you do? How do you let yourself be just so free falling and not be worried about the other shoe dropping?
Dr. Jennifer Reid: Well, I think recognizing again, what is the cost? What do you miss out on when you're doing this? And I like to go back and I'll say, let's talk about the past decade maybe. And how many times have you had this kind of anticipation like, why better not be too excited because then I'm going to feel really badly.
Tamsen Fadal: Oh, I every time I have something big planned,
Dr. Jennifer Reid: How often did it go as badly as you imagined?
Tamsen Fadal: Like never, right?
Dr. Jennifer Reid: And so I think what is the cost of all that time spent, essentially living that bad outcome? Because sometimes our brain doesn't know what's the difference between reality and what we're imagining. So you're putting yourself through that and you're missing out on moments of joy and wonder and peace because you think that this can somehow protect you.
Tamsen Fadal: I want to talk about um learning to disappoint people. I don't even like those words, Jennifer, but I'm going to say them. How do you learn to disappoint people knowing you might and being okay with that moving forward?
Dr. Jennifer Reid: Well, I think first it's knowing that you must. You must disappoint people. That there's no way to avoid disappointing people unless you literally cut yourself off from everybody, right? Because I can't be in multiple places at once. I'm here talking with you, so I'm not at home. My kid forgets something at school. I'm not there to bring it to him, right? So we can't go about our world, our day-to-day without disappointing others. What I want us to see is that disappointment is like any emotion. It's temporary. It's a signal that something happened that triggered that emotion, but it's not dangerous, right? It's not debilitating. And I think the more that we try to immediately like fix it or take it away from someone, what we're suggesting to them and ourselves is that it is dangerous. Like you can't feel disappointment otherwise or else. And I might ask someone to say, what what else?
Like what would happen if your friend was disappointed because you couldn't go to their event? Well, they would never want to talk to me again. Like what are those catastrophic thoughts that come out? And it's important for them to say those out loud because we can say something to ourselves over and over again and until we put it out there, we don't realize, oh wait, you're right. That does sound like really unfair.
Tamsen Fadal: Do you suggest people say it out loud or write it down or actually listen to it it sounds very unfair to you, right? It sounds like you're being unfair to yourself.
Dr. Jennifer Reid: Absolutely. So yeah, to say it out loud, to write it down. I think journaling can be really helpful. I think to sort of see it out there on paper, it gives us little objectivity from it that it's not just circling in our brains. And I think that's one of the powers of therapy or talking to a really trusted friend or someone you know is going to be real with you because hearing yourself say that out loud you can actually start to sort of chip away about how how true that really feels.
Tamsen Fadal: You know I think a lot of our listeners are in a stage where they're, you know, trying to figure out what they want to do next. Maybe they want to make a change in their careers, maybe they're trying to balance everything, balance being liked and respected and and trusted. What changes when a woman starts to make that shift of being okay with disappointing other people as she's trying to move into her next chapter?
Dr. Jennifer Reid: Well something I learned in studying family therapy and couples therapy in training was that the family is going to resist any change. Even if the system is sort of chaotic and there's a lot of conflict, there's resistance to change. So if the woman decides I'm going to start saying no sometimes and not being the one that will always take on the additional shift at work for example or project or childcare, there's going to be some resistance from the people in her life. And so I think it's preparing her for that knowing that yeah you might get some pushback when I ask my son to open, you know, unstack the dishwasher. I get I get a tone that's not my favorite tone, but I still say okay great, you know. So how do you start recognize that that's going to come back at you but know like having the confidence that there's something important about making this change.
Like I'm important enough to have a life where I don't feel constantly exhausted or resentful or guilty and that's going to allow me to live this life I want.
Tamsen Fadal: So what do you do? You just have to keep acting you don't you don't acknowledge that pushback and just keep moving forward and so you're you're basically teaching people how to treat you?
Dr. Jennifer Reid: You really we are always training people how to treat us. So, absolutely, and yes: I don't love that tone coming back, and I might say, "You know, that's unfair." But it doesn't mean I'm going to say, "Well, never mind, I'll just do it myself," because I think we can get into that habit, or we might feel guilty, and then because guilt, when it's adaptive, tells us to go and fix it do something more. And so when we feel constant guilt we're always taking on more and more and more until we feel like we're doing everything. Why am I the only one X, Y, and Z, right? And part of that is if we're feeling more guilt, we're more likely to take those things on ourselves. That's what we need to start pushing back on because you having a minute to yourself is actually really important. And it makes sense and it's fair. It isn't selfish.
Tamsen Fadal: You know, the goal is not to remove every experience of guilt, right? That's not what we're trying to do. And you want us to stop allowing that excessive guilt to make these decisions for us. You created a five-step framework called SPEAK to move from guilt toward agency. Can we walk through the speak framework?
Dr. Jennifer Reid: Sure. I love that. So framework sounds so so scientific, doesn't it?
Tamsen Fadal: Yeah, so official.
Dr. Jennifer Reid: So starting with so SPEAK, S is showing up. And again, this is allowing us to pay attention to ourselves, which it sounds simple, but I wanted to acknowledge it because that's so important that women can do that, that their their life matters too. The P is for paying attention and that really is what are these thoughts, these critical thoughts, these guilty thoughts that are showing up, maybe every time I walk in the door when I come home from work, every time I get off the phone with my parents, right? What is it that's showing up to start to notice that? And what I want to acknowledge in that moment is sometimes there's grief that can come out for women because they start to notice how awful they've been treating themselves for so long. And so let's acknowledge that. Yeah, that's really hard. But then continuing to pay that attention.
The E is for examining those thoughts. So again, where are they most common? We might want to start there, right? If there's a role where we feel constant guilt and another one where we can delegate and disappoint and it's okay, we might want to start with the one where there's the most guilt. So we examine that. We come up with what are these expectations that we're carrying? We look at that perceived reality like we spoke about earlier. The A, I needed some action. I need to take action. So both the action of how do we rewrite this rough draft thoughts that are these guiltier critical thoughts, but also learning to delegate and some of the tone that comes back, but knowing it's important, learning how to disappoint. And then the third one there being setting boundaries. And I think boundaries, it's important to frame that as this is scaffolding that allows us to engage and move toward each other.
This is not a wall between us. This is me saying this is how I can safely engage with you. I want to do so. Let's let's try and work together. And then the K, most importantly, is to keep going, that it is a practice. It's a repetition. We're trying to retrain the brain, rewrite these stories, and that can take time and practice.
Tamsen Fadal: Before we finish, come back to the idea that guilt has become this like internal compass for a lot of women, especially women in midlife. If guilt has guided decisions for such a long time in your life, what do you put in its place?
Dr. Jennifer Reid: Well, instead of should, right? So much of that's what it's coming up with is should. We want what do I want? What do I need? What's a deep desire that I carry, right? What brings me joy? And sometimes women, often women will say, I don't even know the answers to that, right?
Tamsen Fadal: I I know I don't.
Dr. Jennifer Reid: Right? So we might be okay, again, where journaling can come in. Maybe it's going back to that time before we went through adolescence. What were the things that we really enjoyed as a little girl? And I think sometimes that can be an arrow to point us in that direction because we start in adolescence and beyond looking outward, how can we care for those out there? And really in midlife, I hope that we can turn kind of back inward. I mean, anytime of life frankly, but midlife as your children are growing or other caretaking duties are changing, let's turn back in and say what what makes me me? And I think that can be a really joyful journey, but maybe a little bit longer one for some.
Tamsen Fadal: Do you feel like you have a lot of people coming into you during this time in life with these transitions of perimenopause and menopause and saying, "Hey, I want I want to reestablish who I am and I don't want to feel like this anymore and I do want to allow myself to be happy and vulnerable?"
Dr. Jennifer Reid: I do and I'm really encouraged by that. There's this potential energy that I hear from women at this stage of life, which is again, I've put so much time and effort like a working mom who just can multitask all day long, right? She's her children may be stepping away or other duties are calming down and she has all this energy. And so that is really exciting. So if we can find a way to say, hey, this is actually a time of opportunity as opposed to I need to have it all figured out. You don't have to have it all figured out, but maybe it's what's the next best step? How do I start to explore what this next day or this next year or next decade might look like?
Tamsen Fadal: Is there for you an unreasonable expectation that you've released and has that changed your life? Especially after writing this book, especially after talking to so many people over the years.
Dr. Jennifer Reid: Well, I've realized in writing it that my father was a physician, and retired now, and my mother stayed home with us. And I realized I was carrying this really potent expectation that I could do both of those roles as well as each of them did, and as kind of complete and involved as each of them did. So I can make homemade dinners every night, and I can see patients until 7:00 or 8:00 p.m. I can't, of course. But I think that was really helpful for me to be like, yes, of course I can't. But wait, then why am I trying? And why am I telling myself if I'm not doing both of those perfectly that I'm not a good mother or a good doctor? And I think that's what I've been working to release. And again, it's a practice. I have to keep going with it, but it's been so helpful to write this and talk to so many women about their experiences.
Tamsen Fadal: Is there one thing that you've heard over and over as women start reclaiming their life from all these expectations?
Dr. Jennifer Reid: They just say, I didn't realize that it was everywhere, that it was a constant companion for me, that I felt guilty about absolutely everything, which I think is amazing. And my next step to them is to say, go find others and talk about it with them. Share these ideas, share your experiences. You can help each other in these different roles. How did I, you know, work on my mom guilt? How did I work on my, you know, daughter guilt? It really can be such a community of women who are working through this together.
Tamsen Fadal: Yeah, it's guilt noise, you know? I mean, it really is. It just sits there all the time and you don't even realize it's there. Jennifer, thank you so much. I was so excited to have you on because when I saw Guilt Free on the cover of a book, I thought I need to know what that is.
Dr. Jennifer Reid: Thank you. Thank you for having me.
medical disclaimer:
The information provided in this podcast is for educational and informational purposes only and is not intended as medical advice. Always consult with a qualified healthcare professional regarding any medical concerns or treatment options. The views expressed by guests are their own and do not necessarily reflect those of The Tamsen Show.






